01-23-2019, 10:50 AM.bojo Wrote:

01-23-2019, 10:36 AMGCool Wrote: And I checked all the other math and it's fine (small caveat: did not check very closely that the TPE was added correctly).

So
1. Where's my $5M for completing the updater job?
2. Should COL really be punished if Incite updated correctly for his whole career and it wasn't determined until he hit the cap that he had added 4 extra TPE?

The updater did point out the error, and either the player or the gm could have made the fix. But it was fixed until today, as the last two posts in the update thread show.

But is it really incite's fault? Debatable, but I'd lean towards no since his updates were correct. Probably more the GM's fault. Idk it's tricky.

While it is an issue that the updater pointed it out on like the 13th and the GM didn't post there for a whole week, this issue has existed since the player was created. Updaters are supposed to audit their teams once a season (I'm going from S25 rules when I was updating still). That means whoever approved the player missed it, and whoever audited Colorado at the end of S44 also missed it.

So yeah, my main point is everything was correct from what Incite and the GMs could see -- until it suddenly wasn't. If you backtrack through each update, it's not obvious that a mistake was made. If the updaters were diligent up front, this would have been a non-issue. That's why I don't think they should be punished at all.

Also it's FOUR TPE my goodness