Option 1:

Most basic tier analysts would lambast Slip McScruff's performance with the Montreal Patriotes.  They would point out his rough performance on the advanced stats.  Worst in the team Fenwick For % Relative, fourth from the bottom Corsi For % Relative, 2nd worst Shots Against per 60 AND 2nd worst Shots For per 60.  But you should consider that he's putting up these numbers in the oldest cohort in the league while also putting up minutes he hasn't seen since his days in Winnipeg (except for an outlier season in Los Angeles).  Montreal trusts him enough to ride the top power play squad and top penalty kill where he's put up 2 power play assists and a shorthanded assist.

Sure, it's impressive that the other two oldies are the best and among the best on all the advanced stats categories.  Sure, Slip McScruff may be third wheeling this old folks power squad.  But, Slip McScruff is the most underrated player on this team because people literally don't bother to rate him.  He's putting up pedestrian numbers with more opportunity than he might deserve, and that's something in year 20... 9? 30?