Create Account

S24 Entry Draft: Rounds 1 & 2
#1

<b><div align="center">S24 Entry Draft: Rounds 1 & 2</div></b>
<div align="center">[Image: 2011_NHLDraftBoard_AB772864711.jpg]</div>

Drafts can be a difficult thing to predict. Some drafts are exceptionally deep, while others end up as more of a one round affair. Others appear deep, before their draft class ultimately loses steam upon entering the SHL proper. S24 was something of a question mark of a draft, even at the time: there were plenty of exciting prospects up for grabs, but the memory of the exceptional drafts that preceded it over the past few seasons made for some potentially unfavourable comparisons. With the draft now eleven seasons behind us, those players who remain from the S24 draft are entering their second season of regression: by now, the peak of each of these players has become abundantly clear.

Although a fair few players in the first round turned out to be busts, or at least didn’t achieve their potential, Season 24 had as many players going late in the second round that managed to establish themselves as excellent players. There were, in effect, as many steals as there were busts in a draft that may not have been as deep as those that preceded it, but that was certainly unpredictable. Although there are players worth noting well after the second round, including the last overall pick who may have earned the right to be called the most memorable prospect in the draft class, this article will not extend into the third round.

<div align="center">Round 1</div>

1. Dragons Calgary Dragons - Randy Randleman

There can be very little disputing this selection for the Dragons. After entering the league in S26, Randleman immediately established himself, becoming rookie of the year before putting up consistent, high scoring seasons in the league. Having played his whole career with the Dragons thus far, he has quickly become one of the faces of the franchise, putting up over 20 goals in eight of his nine seasons, with a career high of 26 goals and 38 assists for 64 points in Season 33. Randleman was a standout in his draft class, and he has remained such to this day. While he may be getting older, he isn’t showing many signs of slowing down, and will likely remain a force for years to come, so long as he remains determined.

2. Platoon West Kendall Platoon - Damien Wert

Wert was highly touted due to his goal scoring prowess and drive to improve, and so his selection at second overall was no surprise to anyone. Initially, Wert didn’t quite live up to the promise: in 350 games with the Platoon, he notched 79 goals and 93 assists, barely over half a point per game. He was loyal to the Platoon for that stretch, but it became clear that he didn’t quite fit in with the Platoon’s system of play. After moving to the Toronto North Stars, he saw his ice-time increase dramatically, and had a breakout year with 51 points and 25 goals. He repeated this success in the next two seasons, with 22 and 19 goal outings, far exceeding his success in West Kendall. Given how much better he’s fit in Toronto, one has to wonder what his career might have looked like if he fell to third overall.

3. Stars Toronto North Stars - Beau Ballard

Beau Ballard is the first real bust on this list -- sort of. His career in Toronto was certainly nothing to write home about, notching just 7 points in his first season, and 11 points in his sophomore campaign. When he moved to Portland in Season 27, his production and ice-time skyrocketed and he put up multiple 40+ point outings. Even so, his career was short-lived and he retired after five seasons with the Admirals. Although his stint in Portland revealed why he was selected third overall, and showed that he had all the skill required to live up to the hype, his short career ultimately undercuts his value as the third overall selection.

4. Jets Winnipeg Jets - Redacted

After being one of the most highly touted players in his draft class, this player made a name for himself as a hard-hitting, scoring star in juniors. Unfortunately, he couldn’t live up to the hype in a case even more dramatic than Ballard: after putting up disappointing campaigns in his rookie and sophomore season, he seemed to give up on hockey, and the league. He was moved to New England where he had even less impressive campaigns, before ultimately vanishing off of the face of the Earth. For a player that was generally expected to be one of the most successful, if boisterous of his class, he was an extreme example of a bust. Some even expected him to go 1st overall until the last week or two before the draft.

5. Steelhawks Hamilton Steelhawks - Brandon Girard

Brandon Girard had a wealth of promise, but ultimately his career was cut short. An offensive defenceman that put up over a point per game in his last campaign in the SMJHL, he couldn’t make his career stick in the league itself. He played a fair number of minutes for the Steelhawks in his first two seasons and put up decent numbers for a young defender, but decided to retire before he could really progress far enough to make his mark on the league. Because of this, he has to be considered another bust, despite his incredible play in juniors.

6. Steelhawks Hamilton Steelhawks - Patrick Brumm

Brumm only played one season for the Steelhawks, but there’s hardly a doubt he was worthy of the sixth overall pick -- higher, given the players selected above him. After joining the new Portland Franchise in S26, he swiftly established himself as a very good offensive defenseman, with campaigns ranging from 30 points to 40 points between Portland and Texas. However, it was once Brumm switched to forward that he really showcased his offensive arsenal, with a near 30-goal season, followed by an even more brilliant 62 point outing in Season 34. Without having to play the blueline, Brumm has been able to make full use of his speed and hands to become one of Seattle’s most important players.

7. Steelhawks Hamilton Steelhawks - N/A

Hamilton was forced to forfeit its original pick in this draft.

8. Wolfpack New England Wolfpack - Buster Killington

Killington may have entered the league as a true rookie, but he didn’t lace up his skates for the New England Wolfpack once. When he joined the league, it wasn’t for the team that drafted him, but rather as one of the young faces of the new Portland Admirals franchise. He quickly established himself as a future star with a 39 point showing in his first season, bettered in his sophomore campaign by two points. In his final season with Portland, he scored 26 goals for 54 points. A fearsome physical presence with the ability to throw out huge hits, Killington could have gone quite far for Portland. Unfortunately, a tampering charge led him to cut his career short. So, this pick could have turned out (albeit not for New England), but simply wasn’t given time.

9. Wolfpack New England Wolfpack - Earnest Ciarelli

The top goaltender selected in this draft, Ciarelli was a starting netminder by Season 27, and a fairly good one at that. Although he had some initial struggles, he quickly established himself as a reliable, if not remarkable starting goaltender -- with a couple very good seasons later in his career. While he eventually saw his ice-time diminish to the point of being a back-up, Ciarelli was a rock for New England, and briefly Texas, and was thus one of the better goaltender selections in the draft.

10. Rage Manhattan Rage - Kyle Prince

Before there was Jason Aittokallio, there was Kyle Prince. As one of the most promising young goaltenders at the time, many suspected Prince to go high -- higher than he did. He was a fixture in juniors that season, talented and more than willing to speak his mind. Even so, his development quickly ground to a halt, and Manhattan gave up on him after a disastrous season as backup in which he recorded a .871 save percentage, letting in 20 goals in 6 games. The next season, he became a starter for the first time with Buffalo -- largely due to a shallow team. He had two unremarkable seasons, winning just twelve games in each season, before leaving the league altogether.

11. Blizzard Edmonton Blizzard - Adam Abodobe

People have asked in the past why Edmonton has historically had such an aversion to drafts. While this past draft was an exception with Edmonton making a host of selections, the choice of Adam Abodobe in the first round in Season 24 provides some suggestion: Edmonton’s scouting was lacking. Thoroughly controversial with some well-publicized spats with other members of his draft class, Abodobe may have had attention on him as he entered the league, but he couldn’t turn that into anything. His career has been longer than most generally accepted ‘busts’, as he played nine seasons for Edmonton before moving to the West Kendall Platoon last season -- but with just 51 points in those 468 games, gone is the offensive powerhouse that appeared in juniors. He’s mostly just a low-minutes roleplayer now, playing as little as 2 minutes in one season.

12. Dragons Calgary Dragons - VLAD McZehrl

This one is tricky. On the face of it, a player who has broken records and had numerous 30+ goal seasons, nearly cracking 40 goals and 80 points this past season, would be a massive steal at twelfth overall. However, McZehrl didn’t drop because of the quality of his player -- everyone knew he was going to be a star player, and he was arguably one of the best players in the draft even back then. He dropped because of off-ice considerations not worth getting into here. So, he isn’t quite a steal: teams that weren’t interested knew full well they were passing on a future all-star, and Calgary realized they could get him with their second first rounder and so opted to pick up the tandem of Randleman and McZehrl together. A value pick to be sure, even if McZehrl quickly left Calgary, only to have his point totals explode into historic proportions in Seattle and Manhattan respectively.

<div align="center">Second Round</div>

13. Chiefs Minnesota Chiefs - Winston Windsor

Winston Windsor was a late entrant to the season, and so there were a lot of questions around his potential in the league. He was a value pick in the second round, putting up a couple of good showings with Minnesota, before eventually being traded to Edmonton. A solid, passing defenceman who’s arguably most valuable on the powerplay, he was a fairly good pick up. Compared to some of the busts earlier, he could have gone in the first round, but at the time there was no real reason to value him above more developed players.

14. Platoon West Kendall Platoon - Anton Fedorov

Anton Fedorov ultimately became the quintessential second round pick. A good player -- but not necessarily a star player. He had a couple unremarkable outings in West Kendall before moving to Los Angeles, where he really began to showcase his talents with 30+ point seasons, and one 49 point season. Although inconsistent, Fedorov was the kind of player that, when he was playing well, could change a game. Overall, a decent second round selection when all's said and done, even if he could have gone a little farther in his career.

15. Renegades Texas Renegades - Igor Ogorodnikov

Ogorodnikov was more or less what he was expected to be for Texas: a locker room figure and a back-up goaltender, with one season as a starter in which he actually performed quite well with 22 wins on the season. Although a superior goaltender to someone like Kyle Prince, he was generally known as a player destined for Texas eventually -- so there was really no point in anyone else picking him. He was a back-up goaltender who posted only two losing seasons in his 8 season career. When playoff races are tight, back-ups are important -- and so too was Ogorodnikov, in that sense.

16. Blizzard Edmonton Blizzard - Richard D’Amour

D’Amour was initially one of the more highly sought after prospects in the league, but his stock fell after there were some doubts about his dedication to the league. He played three seasons for the Blizzard, playing fairly well defensively but not really managing to stand out at all, before moving to Minnesota in an exchange for fellow draftee Windsor. It was in Minnesota that D’Amour really began to shine -- as a locker room leader and character guy. In Seasons 31 and 32, he transitioned into a much more prominent player, doubling his ice-time and recording 23 and 22 points respectively for his best campaign yet. Given how Minnesota reinvigorated him, one has to wonder what kind of career he could have had if he were that motivated the entire time.

17. Stars Toronto North Stars - Shea Robinson

One of many players on this list that ended up in Portland for his rookie season, rather than Toronto, Robinson etched out an 8 season career as a second to third pairing defenceman. He played his fair share of minutes, mainly defensively, and although he never really stood out as a star player, teams generally knew what they were getting from him: a utility defenceman capable of bigger minutes when required, particularly for shallow teams that need it desperately.

18. Stars Toronto North Stars - Nick Leier

Nick Leier is an odd case. He -too- saw his rookie season with Portland, but it wasn’t one or two seasons after his draft date like most players in that situation. It took Leier eight seasons after his initial draft date to crack the league, in his only outing. In Season 32, the rookie Leier recorded 9 points in 50 games with the Admirals. He really didn’t make much of his career, but at least he made it to the SHL.

19. Platoon West Kendall Platoon - Klaus Wagner

Similar to Ogorodnikov, everyone knew Wagner was going to join the Platoon one way or another -- and thus why he dropped. That’s the only way to explain it away, as Wagner has been an extremely consistent defender, with the ability to put up a fair amount of points. In fact, while he may not score as highly as other defenseman on this list season after season, his peak far exceeds most, with Season 31 featuring a 54 point outing from Wagner. A steal, but one that was more or less guaranteed to fall to the Platoon.

20. Panthers Los Angeles Panthers - Kaapo Kekkonen

It took Kekkonen a little while to establish himself, with his first four seasons in the league being fairly average overall -- but once he did, he was set. A perennial 35 to 45 point scorer that has begun to throw a ton of hits, Kekkonen provides a unique presence for the Panthers. For a second round pick, he came at incredible value. While recently he has established himself as an excellent playmaker, Kekkonen has also shown himself to be an excellent goal-scorer with a couple of 20 goal seasons.

21. Riot Seattle Riot - Reginald Howard

Reginald Howard would begin his rookie campaign for the Stampede, not the Riot, and had a pretty good outing at that, with 33 points. Unfortunately, that was the best he ever managed, and Howard’s production declined steadily over the next two seasons in Buffalo. When he eventually moved to Minnesota, he saw one 10 goal season, followed by three seasons in which he registered less than 10 points overall. Seasons 32 and 33 were his last with the team, but featured something of a resurgence with two 20 point seasons. An inconsistent career with plenty of ups and downs, Howard will ultimately be judged by his locker room presence more than his impact on the ice.

22. Rage Manhattan Rage - Mirko Antonio Scuderi

Scuderi never really amounted to much in the league, even though there was enough promise there that Manhattan thought they might be able to spark a fire in him to improve. In his two proper seasons in the SHL, with Buffalo, he recorded 9 and 11 points respectively, before leaving the league due to lack of interest. He couldn’t really keep up with SHL level players, and with the state of the game growing more difficult for low to mid-level journeymen players, there was no place for him in most team’s lineups.

23. Jets Winnipeg Jets - Ray Pejonis

Ray Pejonis was yet another player that joined with a different team - specifically, with the Stampede. The league expansion really threw the draft into flux. As a member of the Stampede, the Platoon, and the Admirals, Pejonis has established himself as an extremely solid player -- the type of player that should lead general managers not to throw away their second round picks as meaningless tradebait.

24. Jets Winnipeg Jets - Patrick Taylor

Ending this list is Patrick Taylor. After being an extremely hyped prospect early, Taylor diminished a little in terms of draft stock. Even so, he clawed his way back up, changed his name, and has since established himself as a star offensive player. After leaving Winnipeg, he became a key piece in the new generation of the New England Wolfpack - the most dominant version of the Wolfpack in its history. As the last pick in the second round, and the last pick that will be discussed on this list, Patrick Taylor aka Patrikov Bure has to be regarded as a rather extreme steal at this point in the draft.

Conclusion

Season 24 had a wealth of star players, many of whom continue to play today. If there were to be a redraft, it would certainly look very different from what really took place, as a surprising number of players either didn’t play up to their potential, exceeded their potential, or played about as well as they were expected to - but quickly left or were traded to different teams. Only a couple players discussed here established themselves as key players on the teams that drafted them, due to a combination of poor locker room or on-ice chemistry, and the simple fact that the league expanded the very next season, leading many to be taken away by either the Buffalo Stampede or the Portland Admirals.

So, while the draft was fairly deep and did contain its fair share of excellent players, it was not a clean draft, exactly. It becomes very difficult to argue who was and wasn’t a ‘steal’, a ‘bust’, or any other category, when players so often left their draft teams either at the end of their first contract, or during their first contract. With the S35 draft now behind us, it will be interesting to watch to see if the most recent draft on the cusp between spring and summer follows a similar trend.

[Image: wopo0De.png]
Signature Credit: Wasty






Reply
#2

a weird draft in hindsight

[Image: sIjpJeQ.png]





Reply
#3

Quote:Originally posted by WannabeFinn@Jun 3 2017, 05:57 PM
a weird draft in hindsight
Can't believe you were drafted ahead of me



All-time New England Wolfpack scorer
[Image: Derisraka.png]
[Image: 38718_s.png]
[Image: rW2c4Vz.png][Image: B4x6AQm.png]
[Image: YztPk3T.png] [Image: 6by0kBi.png]
Reply
#4

I'm pretty sure you are the first person ever to compliment Ciarelli.

Thanks bby.

Suck it <a href='index.php?showuser=1765' rel='nofollow' alt='profile link' class='user-tagged mgroup-4'>Eggy216</a>

[Image: SigStorm.png]
[Image: QHLWtic.png?1]
san francisco group of cats - mikael koskinen
quebec city citadelz  - mikael koskinen
Reply
#5

My draft year.
Reply




Users browsing this thread:
1 Guest(s)




Navigation

 

Extra Menu

 

About us

The Simulation Hockey League is a free online forums based sim league where you create your own fantasy hockey player. Join today and create your player, become a GM, get drafted, sign contracts, make trades and compete against hundreds of players from around the world.