Sig 1 & 2: 3/5 = 750K, 750K
These are really good, and the jersey swaps look tight as hell. The nautical elements and color scheme and spacing of both signatures is fantastic. The typeface choices and their respective layer styles make sense and contribute positively to the pieces.
Two notes for improvement: when you do a full color swap in the style that you have, make a levels adjustment layer above the new artificial color so that you can bring up the blacks/shadows and the color maintains the depth of the jersey thats behind it (if that didnt make sense, let me know). and: once you get the depth in the jersey colors, tweak the levels of the entire jersey and then the player. currently the faces look like they are being affected by different light sources than the jerseys. once these are pretty close, check out the "camera raw filter" to really play with the shadows/highlights exposure/clarity/contrast etc. and get a few (not too many) layers over top of the player (or just behind) to help blend the player in with the background (in sig 1, the drop shadow looks good and reflects the light appropriately).