Sig 1: 1/5 - 250K
The text and background matching looks pretty good, but it doesn't blend well with the player render. The player is placed a little awkwardly, and scaled in a way that the player looks super low resolution. While the artist is occasionally limited by the source material, using sharper elements like the noise shadow and crisp text and line focused background just draws attention to the low resolution.
Sig 2: 1/5 - 250K
Baby steps! the render selection looks a bit better, but adding the flare through a luminosity blending mode isn't enough to fully blend the two layers. The spacing and sizing of the player is a bit better. With only a player and background, the text should be a heavier focus, but the layer style looks good, particularly with the background.
Sig 3: 2/5 - 500K
The color values of the render match the model stadium well, which helps tie the two together. The roof modifications were a nice touch to tie in the SHL. The typeface is appropriate, but not sized proportionally or enhanced to tie it in with the rest of the image.
Sig 4: 2/5 - 500K
Your best submission. The background and text work well together, and the noise filter compliments the player render. The blend of the player of the background looks pretty good, but comes off as slightly flattened without the right level controls.