+- Simulation Hockey League (https://simulationhockey.com)
+-- Forum: League Transactions (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=18)
+--- Forum: General Transactions (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=332)
+---- Forum: SHL Roster Transactions (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=224)
+----- Forum: Call-Ups and Send-Downs (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=359)
+----- Thread: S14 Call-Ups and Send Downs (/showthread.php?tid=24706)
- BigTittySmitty - 10-18-2013
Any idea when Toast or JP or both will be online to discuss this and make a ruling. Would hate to hold up the sim.
- Hallsy - 10-18-2013
Quote:Originally posted by Buster@Oct 18 2013, 07:07 PM
So you're basically saying ratings shouldn't be consistent between leagues? That makes no sense.
Please make Nurmi 325 TPE in the SMJHL file so he can be sent down to Detroit and keep him 750 TPE in the SHL file so Edmonton can call him up every now and then
Making and actually being are two different things
- Buster - 10-18-2013
Quote:Originally posted by Hallsy@Oct 18 2013, 09:10 PM
Making and actually being are two different things
Well he's "actually" a 400 TPE player now so.
You also can't see why having two different ratings in two sims isn't plausible. Not surprised though
- Hallsy - 10-18-2013
technically He was never suppose to be updated until yesterday but it should of not reached the sim yet so he should not have had 400 tpe in the sim. he then quickly got sent down again making him a SMJHL player again and making the update invalid.
- Buster - 10-18-2013
Quote:Originally posted by Hallsy@Oct 18 2013, 09:13 PM
technically He was never suppose to be updated until yesterday but it should of not reached the sim yet so he should not have had 400 tpe in the sim. he then quickly got sent down again making him a SMJHL player again and making the update invalid.
Actually no, the update can't just be invalid. Length of call up should have zero effect in the ruling. He was called up, period. As such, he is instantly an updated player whether the update is applied or not. He's up in the SHl, he's a 400 TPE player.
- O4L - 10-18-2013
He shouldn't of been updated, if he is back in the SHL this season then he should be back at 324, and when he returns to the SMJHL he should be at 324. All there really is to it.
- teztify - 10-18-2013
Did he play a game at 400 TPE in the SHL or was he still at 324 during the start?
- Hallsy - 10-18-2013
Quote:Originally posted by teztify@Oct 18 2013, 07:17 PM
Did he play a game at 400 TPE in the SHL or was he still at 324 during the start?
he was 400 tpe but he should of never been updated.
- Buster - 10-18-2013
Quote:Originally posted by teztify@Oct 18 2013, 09:17 PM
Did he play a game at 400 TPE in the SHL or was he still at 324 during the start?
He in fact did
- Buster - 10-18-2013
Quote:Originally posted by Hallsy@Oct 18 2013, 09:18 PM
he was 400 tpe but he should of never been updated.
So you're saying he's a 400 TPE player who played a game at 400 TPE?
- Hallsy - 10-18-2013
Quote:Originally posted by Buster@Oct 18 2013, 07:16 PM
Actually no, the update can't just be invalid. Length of call up should have zero effect in the ruling. He was called up, period. As such, he is instantly an updated player whether the update is applied or not. He's up in the SHl, he's a 400 TPE player.
He's not a 400 tpe yet as he was never supposed to be updated. Updater made a mistake as SMJHL players can't have over 325 tpe and at the time of all of the updates except the most recent one which happened early due him being away early. IF fourfour was on any other team with a different updater who usually update on the weekends, he should of never been updated at all. why affect the player because he has a different updater that made mistakes while updating fourfour.
- Hallsy - 10-18-2013
Quote:Originally posted by Buster@Oct 18 2013, 07:18 PM
So you're saying he's a 400 TPE player who played a game at 400 TPE?
Yes but the update was never suppose to happen, can you be so dumb?
- Buster - 10-18-2013
Quote:Originally posted by Hallsy@Oct 18 2013, 09:21 PM
He's not a 400 tpe yet as he was never supposed to be updated. Updater made a mistake as SMJHL players can't have over 325 tpe and at the time of all of the updates except the most recent one which happened early due him being away early. IF fourfour was on any other team with a different updater who usually update on the weekends, he should of never been updated at all. why affect the player because he has a different updater that made mistakes while updating fourfour.
Who cares if it was early? He's played a game at 400 TPE. He is officially a 400 TPE player
- Buster - 10-18-2013
Quote:Originally posted by Hallsy@Oct 18 2013, 09:22 PM
Yes but the update was never suppose to happen, can you be so dumb?
Did he play a game at 400 TPE?
- Hallsy - 10-18-2013
Quote:Originally posted by Buster@Oct 18 2013, 07:22 PM
Who cares if it was early? He's played a game at 400 TPE. He is officially a 400 TPE player
he was never suppose to be a 400 tpe as the recent update as yet to be put in and that should of been the time where he was fully updated to 400tpe.