+- Simulation Hockey League (https://simulationhockey.com)
+-- Forum: SHL History (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: SHL History (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=59)
+---- Forum: Awards (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=31)
+---- Thread: S63 SHL Awards Show (/showthread.php?tid=122818)
RE: S63 SHL Awards Show - brickwall35 - 03-13-2022
03-13-2022, 08:13 PMluke Wrote:Why? Not like they're around to even acknowledge the award win. Make it actives only. It's not like there aren't a plethora of potential active nominees for each award.03-13-2022, 08:11 PMbrickwall35 Wrote: Can you as a group seriously not find 3 active users who had a good enough season to be nominated for ROTY?
Both J and SHL award committees need complete overhauls.
I disagree on the fact that a goalie who played 13 games got nommed. But the best players should always be nominated regardless of activity status
RE: S63 SHL Awards Show - AgentSmith630 - 03-13-2022
Just a reminder that that 200 TPE IA Rookie Goalie went 11-2 in one of the toughest divisions/conferences in the league. While I agree that the IA rule from the SMJHL should also be implemented in the SHL, this discussion would not be happening (regardless of TPE) if he was any sort of active.
RE: S63 SHL Awards Show - Tomen - 03-13-2022
03-13-2022, 08:34 PMAgentSmith630 Wrote: Just a reminder that that 200 TPE IA Rookie Goalie went 11-2 in one of the toughest divisions/conferences in the league. While I agree that the IA rule from the SMJHL should also be implemented in the SHL, this discussion would not be happening (regardless of TPE) if he was any sort of active.That discussion would still be happening because this goalie played less minutes this season than any skater who played all 66 games. IDGAF about the activity status but it should be all about the performance of the entire year since it's ROTY. Normally goalies have almost double the minutes played compared to skaters... so a real head scratcher by the Awards team from my POV.
RE: S63 SHL Awards Show - Accka - 03-13-2022
Good luck Lev!!
RE: S63 SHL Awards Show - CementHands - 03-13-2022
03-13-2022, 08:13 PMluke Wrote:03-13-2022, 08:11 PMbrickwall35 Wrote: Can you as a group seriously not find 3 active users who had a good enough season to be nominated for ROTY?
Both J and SHL award committees need complete overhauls.
I disagree on the fact that a goalie who played 13 games got nommed. But the best players should always be nominated regardless of activity status
I gotta disagree Luke. What is th point of nominating someone who is IA for any award. Can you make a serious argument that no one else active would have been a good nomination instead? It's a joke.
RE: S63 SHL Awards Show - Henrik - 03-14-2022
Let's go Pride!
Extremely excited to see so many names up there for us, although I cant say I agree with giving an IA player an award nomination.
RE: S63 SHL Awards Show - trella - 03-14-2022
Mike fitted snubbed for every award
RE: S63 SHL Awards Show - PremierBromanov - 03-14-2022
All credit to dwight on this one. Thanks for the nom!
RE: S63 SHL Awards Show - PremierBromanov - 03-14-2022
also geekusiod robbed.
RE: S63 SHL Awards Show - luke - 03-14-2022
03-13-2022, 11:52 PMCementHands Wrote:03-13-2022, 08:13 PMluke Wrote: I disagree on the fact that a goalie who played 13 games got nommed. But the best players should always be nominated regardless of activity status
I gotta disagree Luke. What is th point of nominating someone who is IA for any award. Can you make a serious argument that no one else active would have been a good nomination instead? It's a joke.
Oh I know it’s not one of the most popular opinion , for me, I think the best players should be voted on the award regardless of the activity status. Have it be the best players. And then what if that person returns from inactivity and finds out they weren’t nominated because they went inactive. Just my opinion
RE: S63 SHL Awards Show - Zoone16 - 03-14-2022
LDV not nommed? good. he was trash this past year regardless of all his wins.
RE: S63 SHL Awards Show - RomanesEuntDomus - 03-14-2022
Since I'm a bit of an idiot and messed up timezones and daylight savings, there will be a slight delay and the show will start at 5pm instead!
RE: S63 SHL Awards Show - RomanesEuntDomus - 03-14-2022
The show is starting in 20 minutes but the red carpet is already open, so feel free to post your pictures and get hyped!
RE: S63 SHL Awards Show - RomanesEuntDomus - 03-14-2022
Welcome to the Season 63 SHL Awards Show! Tonight we honor some of the best players in the SHL as well as some incredible behind the scenes personnel. There are many great people in this league both on and off the ice and only a handful of them can take home an Award each season. Just being nominated for some of these is already a great honor as is getting votes during the process even if you don’t end up getting a nomination. So be proud of your achievements no matter if you hear your name called today or not and to those of you who do take home some hardware, make sure to celebrate it properly.
Just to give you a little bit of insight on the process, the SHL Awards consist of both pre-determined Awards (Most Goals in a season, Best Team in the regular season etc.) and voted Awards. The latter category is arguably the more exciting and important one and most of these are determined by the voters in the SHL Awards Committee. This season, six voters participated in the creation of the ballots. The first determined the three nominees for each Award in an open nomination phase and then proceeded to vote for the Winner out of these three in a separate second phase. If you have missed them so far, you can find the nominees in the opening post in this thread.
But enough with the talking talk, let’s get to it now…
RE: S63 SHL Awards Show - RomanesEuntDomus - 03-14-2022
As always, feel free to discuss the nominees & winners in here and whether you agree with them or not, but please keep it respectful. You can also post your own predictions for the voted Awards, maybe I'll do a little cash prize if enough people post their own personal ballots here...