+- Simulation Hockey League (https://simulationhockey.com)
+-- Forum: Community (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=17)
+--- Forum: SHL Discussion (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=49)
+--- Thread: All Time Franchise Lineups (/showthread.php?tid=94519)
RE: All Time Franchise Lineups - DeletedAtUserRequest - 03-18-2019
03-18-2019, 03:04 AMSlashACM Wrote: Hold up @Mike Izzywhere's NOLA all time squad at
In the spirit of league comradary...I have added chi town and Nola to the OP
RE: All Time Franchise Lineups - SlashACM - 03-18-2019
03-18-2019, 03:25 PMMike Izzy Wrote:03-18-2019, 03:04 AMSlashACM Wrote: Hold up @Mike Izzywhere's NOLA all time squad at
In the spirit of league comradary...I have added chi town and Nola to the OP
Code:
: :specters:
[u]1st Line[/u]:
C - DeMaricus Smyth
F - Piotr Czerkawski
F - Roman Augustus
D - Adam Kaiser
D - Richard Physt
[u]2nd Line[/u]:
C - Oisin Fletcher
F - Joe Kurczewski
F - Xavier Paquette
D - Karl Hefeweizen
D - Clint Eastwood
[u]3rd Line[/u]:
C - Alex Andani
F - Vasily Horvat
F - Nicholas Williams
D - Sean Stevenson Jr.
D - Patrick Brumm Jr.
[u]4th Line[/u]:
C - Michael Fox
F - Soren Kierkgaard
F - Jimmy Slothface
D - Osbert Whacker
D - Basil Magnicotta
G - Mike Hunt
G - Nathan CoscoRE: All Time Franchise Lineups - Blastmeaway - 03-18-2019
03-17-2019, 01:56 PMKeygan Wrote:
1st Line:
C - Nikolaus Scholz
F - Theo Kane
F - Cory Knouse
D - Tor Tuck
D - Jackson Rodgers-Tanaka
2nd Line:
C - Sergei Karpotsev
F - Ivan Koroviev
F - Jay McDonald
D - Friedrich Muller
D - Cole Reinhart
3rd Line:
C - Kyle Keenan
F - Teddy Cuddles
F - Lucas Smith
D - Winston Windsor
D - Brady McIntyre
4th Line:
C - Teodurs Cukurs
F - Hercules Rockefeller
F - Chico Salmon
D - Connor Tanner
D - Barney Stinson
G - Jakub Aittokalio
G - Brett Broadway
G - Tommy Tuck
Fuck your rules, I'm putting three goalies, they're all amazing
Weow the disrespecc. DMS doesnt even get an honoarable mention for being the BEST 3C ever
RE: All Time Franchise Lineups - JSS - 03-18-2019
03-18-2019, 12:57 PMWannabeFinn Wrote:
1st Line:
C - Eduard Selich
F - Maximilian Wachter
F - Viktor Marius
D - Alexis Metzler
D - Charles Walker
2nd Line:
C - Viktor Vorkampfer
F - Luke Atmey
F - Robb Wind
D - Tatu Mäkelä
D - Friedrich Müller
3rd Line:
C - Dermot Lavelle
F - VLAD McZehrl
F - TJ Bayley
D - Brynjar Tusk
D - GOD McZehrl
4th Line:
C - Nicolas Winter
F - Adrian Thomaz
F - Kevin Hamilton
D - Fredrich Koenig
D - Ludwig Koch Schroder
G - Jordin FourFour Jr.
G - Casey Holmes
I tried to go with a combo of contribution while on the team + longevity with the team. There are some quality players like Stryker, Burton, Stinson, etc. that just weren’t here long enough to really command a spot on the all-time team. I’d expect this list to change a lot over the next few seasons.
Lagerfield robbed imho
RE: All Time Franchise Lineups - White Cornerback - 03-18-2019
03-18-2019, 04:04 PMJSS Wrote:03-18-2019, 12:57 PMWannabeFinn Wrote:
1st Line:
C - Eduard Selich
F - Maximilian Wachter
F - Viktor Marius
D - Alexis Metzler
D - Charles Walker
2nd Line:
C - Viktor Vorkampfer
F - Luke Atmey
F - Robb Wind
D - Tatu Mäkelä
D - Friedrich Müller
3rd Line:
C - Dermot Lavelle
F - VLAD McZehrl
F - TJ Bayley
D - Brynjar Tusk
D - GOD McZehrl
4th Line:
C - Nicolas Winter
F - Adrian Thomaz
F - Kevin Hamilton
D - Fredrich Koenig
D - Ludwig Koch Schroder
G - Jordin FourFour Jr.
G - Casey Holmes
I tried to go with a combo of contribution while on the team + longevity with the team. There are some quality players like Stryker, Burton, Stinson, etc. that just weren’t here long enough to really command a spot on the all-time team. I’d expect this list to change a lot over the next few seasons.
Lagerfield robbed imho
no traitors shitcunt
RE: All Time Franchise Lineups - JumpierPegasus - 03-18-2019
03-18-2019, 09:07 AMBaelor Swift Wrote:
1st Line:
C - Terrance Nova
F - Lord Pretty Flacko
F - Pedro Sarantez
D - Alonzo Garbanzo
D - Noctis Caelum
2nd Line:
C - Chernika Banananov
F - Zach Miller
F - Halfdan Thorstein
D - Niclas Wastlund
D - Walter White
3rd Line:
C - Derrick Glover
F - David Winter
F - Nick Fisher
D - Eero Hamalainen
D - Jackson Turska
4th Line:
C - Eric Pelletier
F - Brodie Witzel
F - Sebastian Strange
D - Sean Stevenson
D - Isak Odegard
G - Robert Andersson
G - Brandon Sawyer
My only relevant player...
Miss Minnesota... feels like a lifetime ago
RE: All Time Franchise Lineups - Samsung virtual assistant - 03-18-2019
03-18-2019, 04:16 PMJumpierPancakes Wrote:03-18-2019, 09:07 AMBaelor Swift Wrote:
1st Line:
C - Terrance Nova
F - Lord Pretty Flacko
F - Pedro Sarantez
D - Alonzo Garbanzo
D - Noctis Caelum
2nd Line:
C - Chernika Banananov
F - Zach Miller
F - Halfdan Thorstein
D - Niclas Wastlund
D - Walter White
3rd Line:
C - Derrick Glover
F - David Winter
F - Nick Fisher
D - Eero Hamalainen
D - Jackson Turska
4th Line:
C - Eric Pelletier
F - Brodie Witzel
F - Sebastian Strange
D - Sean Stevenson
D - Isak Odegard
G - Robert Andersson
G - Brandon Sawyer
My only relevant player...
Miss Minnesota... feels like a lifetime ago
Old man
RE: All Time Franchise Lineups - JSS - 03-18-2019
03-18-2019, 04:11 PMWhite Cornerback Wrote:03-18-2019, 04:04 PMJSS Wrote: Lagerfield robbed imho
no traitors shitcunt
wts
RE: All Time Franchise Lineups - ztevans - 03-18-2019
The Jets one is hard af and I tried to use the data as best as I could to base F/W on which position the player started with, but I won't swear 100% authenticity. Would love to hear others' thoughts on this, especially people like @Leafs4ever or @Bonk. Ranking the "Leafs trio" was particularly difficult for me. Einstein was the most prolific without the individual accolades of Uppercut or Littleton.
I may also be guilty of some recency bias, especially in the bottom six/four, but comparing across eras is hard.
1st Line:
C - Ron Mexico
F - Vidrik Onoprienko
F - Taylor McDavid
D - Big Manious
D - Rembrandt Q. Einstein
2nd Line:
C - Jason Visser
F - Corey Bearss
F - Zach Evans
D - Lance Uppercut
D - Max Weber
3rd Line:
C - Luke Fleming
F - Elyk
F - Patrik Satan
D - Damian Littleton
D - Scott Robertson
4th Line:
C - Sergei Karpotsov
F - Pietra Volkova
F - Kyle Kylrad
D - Karl Hefeweizen
D - Isaac Cormier-Hale
G - John McBride
G - Lauris Prikulis
(And that's leaving two-time McBride winner Artom Zhumbayev off lmao)
RE: All Time Franchise Lineups - Chris-McZehrl - 03-18-2019
03-18-2019, 01:55 PMMike Izzy Wrote: i know that there are members way more qualified to add the Calgary Dragons list and lineup then i, but ill throw out what i think could be the all time roster and ask any of our dragon historians to add/modify/input.
Forwards:
Randy Randleman
Joe K
Esa Anrikkanen
Alex Mack
shnitfritz Jagr
Nicholas Peterson
Mike Izzy
Shane Gagner
Pierre-Luc Laflamme
Kain Webb
Kari Barkov
Defense:
Michael Boychuck
Roman Augustus
Casey Creller
Vlad Smirnov
Sachimo Zoidberg
Steven Jalopski
Bubba Nuck
Adam Kaiser
Fernando Pergher
Goalie:
Hunter Wong
Ryan Jesster
I really just miss Aidan Richan as Defender
Chris McZ and VLAD McZ had some seasons but not enough and also no real huge impact! Chris with a better time than VLAD.
RE: All Time Franchise Lineups - Chris-McZehrl - 03-18-2019
03-18-2019, 04:29 PMztevans Wrote: The Jets one is hard af and I tried to use the data as best as I could to base F/W on which position the player started with, but I won't swear 100% authenticity. Would love to hear others' thoughts on this, especially people like @Leafs4ever or @Bonk. Ranking the "Leafs trio" was particularly difficult for me. Einstein was the most prolific without the individual accolades of Uppercut or Littleton.
I may also be guilty of some recency bias, especially in the bottom six/four, but comparing across eras is hard.
1st Line:
C - Ron Mexico
F - Vidrik Onoprienko
F - Taylor McDavid
D - Big Manious
D - Rembrandt Q. Einstein
2nd Line:
C - Jason Visser
F - Corey Bearss
F - Zach Evans
D - Lance Uppercut
D - Max Weber
3rd Line:
C - Luke Fleming
F - Elyk
F - Patrik Satan
D - Damian Littleton
D - Scott Robertson
4th Line:
C - Sergei Karpotsov
F - Pietra Volkova
F - Kyle Kylrad
D - Karl Hefeweizen
D - Isaac Cormier-Hale
G - John McBride
G - Lauris Prikulis
(And that's leaving two-time McBride winner Artom Zhumbayev off lmao)
VLAD had a good season but that is it! just one season and for that it isnt enough for those lines! but in the other case ... Karpotsov must have also just one season because his player was existing 2 season what I know
RE: All Time Franchise Lineups - Chris-McZehrl - 03-18-2019
03-18-2019, 12:57 PMWannabeFinn Wrote:
1st Line:
C - Eduard Selich
F - Maximilian Wachter
F - Viktor Marius
D - Alexis Metzler
D - Charles Walker
2nd Line:
C - Viktor Vorkampfer
F - Luke Atmey
F - Robb Wind
D - Tatu Mäkelä
D - Friedrich Müller
3rd Line:
C - Dermot Lavelle
F - VLAD McZehrl
F - TJ Bayley
D - Brynjar Tusk
D - GOD McZehrl
4th Line:
C - Nicolas Winter
F - Adrian Thomaz
F - Kevin Hamilton
D - Fredrich Koenig
D - Ludwig Koch Schroder
G - Jordin FourFour Jr.
G - Casey Holmes
I tried to go with a combo of contribution while on the team + longevity with the team. There are some quality players like Stryker, Burton, Stinson, etc. that just weren’t here long enough to really command a spot on the all-time team. I’d expect this list to change a lot over the next few seasons.
uhhh ... VLAD? he was under a point per game!? and he was on BUF for just two seasons!?
RE: All Time Franchise Lineups - ztevans - 03-18-2019
03-18-2019, 04:33 PMChris-McZehrl Wrote:03-18-2019, 04:29 PMztevans Wrote: The Jets one is hard af and I tried to use the data as best as I could to base F/W on which position the player started with, but I won't swear 100% authenticity. Would love to hear others' thoughts on this, especially people like @Leafs4ever or @Bonk. Ranking the "Leafs trio" was particularly difficult for me. Einstein was the most prolific without the individual accolades of Uppercut or Littleton.
I may also be guilty of some recency bias, especially in the bottom six/four, but comparing across eras is hard.
1st Line:
C - Ron Mexico
F - Vidrik Onoprienko
F - Taylor McDavid
D - Big Manious
D - Rembrandt Q. Einstein
2nd Line:
C - Jason Visser
F - Corey Bearss
F - Zach Evans
D - Lance Uppercut
D - Max Weber
3rd Line:
C - Luke Fleming
F - Elyk
F - Patrik Satan
D - Damian Littleton
D - Scott Robertson
4th Line:
C - Sergei Karpotsov
F - Pietra Volkova
F - Kyle Kylrad
D - Karl Hefeweizen
D - Isaac Cormier-Hale
G - John McBride
G - Lauris Prikulis
(And that's leaving two-time McBride winner Artom Zhumbayev off lmao)
VLAD had a good season but that is it! just one season and for that it isnt enough for those lines! but in the other case ... Karpotsov must have also just one season because his player was existing 2 season what I know
I tended to favor longevity. If Karpotsov hadn't been in the Jets HOF I probably would have left him off ... especially since those two seasons aren't in the Bojo Box at all. I'm kinda just taking the league's word on it that he was good enough to get a trophy named after him and get honored by the Jets
RE: All Time Franchise Lineups - Chris-McZehrl - 03-18-2019
03-18-2019, 04:36 PMztevans Wrote:03-18-2019, 04:33 PMChris-McZehrl Wrote: VLAD had a good season but that is it! just one season and for that it isnt enough for those lines! but in the other case ... Karpotsov must have also just one season because his player was existing 2 season what I know
I tended to favor longevity. If Karpotsov hadn't been in the Jets HOF I probably would have left him off ... especially since those two seasons aren't in the Bojo Box at all. I'm kinda just taking the league's word on it that he was good enough to get a trophy named after him and get honored by the Jets
I am not sure but Karpotsov was one season on WPG and one season on EDM?
I still dont know why a player is in the HoF for just two seasons :D
RE: All Time Franchise Lineups - O4L - 03-18-2019
03-18-2019, 01:55 PMMike Izzy Wrote: i know that there are members way more qualified to add the Calgary Dragons list and lineup then i, but ill throw out what i think could be the all time roster and ask any of our dragon historians to add/modify/input.
Forwards:
Randy Randleman
Joe K
Esa Anrikkanen
Alex Mack
shnitfritz Jagr
Nicholas Peterson
Mike Izzy
Shane Gagner
Pierre-Luc Laflamme
Kain Webb
Kari Barkov
Defense:
Michael Boychuck
Roman Augustus
Casey Creller
Vlad Smirnov
Sachimo Zoidberg
Steven Jalopski
Bubba Nuck
Adam Kaiser
Fernando Pergher
Goalie:
Hunter Wong
Ryan Jesster
The only changes I'd make are including Richan and Labsvards on defense. Reggie Williams and Cam Wilson could be included as forwards as well.