08-24-2020, 05:09 PMTheHockeyist Wrote: Talked to StamkosFan in DMs.

OMEGALUL

08-24-2020, 05:07 PMluketd Wrote:

08-24-2020, 05:05 PMGwdjohnson Wrote: I think on appeal the games could def be lowered just going off the precedent of games/TPE cheated that Marius got since Marius got 25 games for cheating 57 TPE (if my numbers are right) but its not that far off the same ratio, maybe 7-8 games would be more fair.

after an appeal karey got 10 games for 57 TPE over

08-24-2020, 05:01 PMbbjygm Wrote:

08-24-2020, 04:53 PMTheHockeyist Wrote: But yes, I do think that a 10-game suspension over 16 TPE due to careless addition mistakes that weren't caught is not justified. If I did a 10 TPE mistake multiple times due to careless addition and it wasn't caught, would I be suspended 10+ games? I think this is unfair to Stamkos and that a lighter punishment should be done instead.

To be fair, there were a multitude of these mistakes. There's a possibility that if they were all individually caught the total punishments would be similar or exceed this current one.

08-24-2020, 05:14 PMJayWhy Wrote: I have a little birdie telling me someone with a vested interest said they were aware of these issues seasons ago, which if true would mean I have a bone to pick. It's hearsay, but it's troubling.

08-24-2020, 05:14 PMJayWhy Wrote:

08-24-2020, 05:01 PMbbjygm Wrote: To be fair, there were a multitude of these mistakes. There's a possibility that if they were all individually caught the total punishments would be similar or exceed this current one.

To be fair, in the history of the league, we have never had punishments for low tpe overages like the max he had was I think 4 in one of them. That kind of thing is just a simple correction.

Also to be fair, by precedent it took over 50 tpe of cap adding errors to get 10 games before.

Also to be fair, this is playoffs vs regular season.

Shall I continue with your "fair"?

I would like a name of who requested this audit. While it was good that it was caught, and I'm not disputing that, I would dare you to tell me with a straight face this league isn't spiteful and looks for every edge. If an audit is requested, I think it should be public knowledge because for some, I'm sure it's tactical and I have a little birdie telling me someone with a vested interest said they were aware of these issues seasons ago, which if true would mean I have a bone to pick. It's hearsay, but it's troubling.

08-24-2020, 05:10 PMBuster Wrote:

08-24-2020, 05:05 PMGwdjohnson Wrote: I think on appeal the games could def be lowered just going off the precedent of games/TPE cheated that Marius got since Marius got 25 games for cheating 57 TPE (if my numbers are right) but its not that far off the same ratio, maybe 7-8 games would be more fair.

It’s playoffs though. I know the NHL uses a sliding scale for playoff games. It’s something like round 1 is 1 playoff game = 2 regular season games and each round starts to go up. I think the finals is something like 1 playoff game = 4-5 regular season games. Basically, importance of games is a factor in the suspension.

Assuming this had malicious intent, which I don’t think it did, this shouldn’t really be more than a 4-5 game suspension. At the very most.