+- Simulation Hockey League (https://simulationhockey.com)
+-- Forum: Community (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=17)
+--- Forum: Announcements (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=24)
+---- Forum: Suspensions/Punishments (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=226)
+---- Thread: REG Budget Violation (/showthread.php?tid=134286)
REG Budget Violation - SchwarzNarr - 12-07-2023
Hello, SMJHL community.
It has come to SMJHL HO's attention that the Regina Elk played a player S73 who was not under contract with the team legally. The player in question was not re-signed by their SHL team and thus was not considered a send down. Unfortunately Regina did not confirm this before the season started, assuming that the player was still on a send down contract. Regina still accounted for the player in their budget, but did not give a proper contract before the season started. This is a budget violation as per SMJHL Rulebook section 10.d.
If a club puts a player on the active roster and a sim goes live without assuming the player’s salary obligations, including a failure to sign the player to a contract and/or deposit said contract, they face the following penalties, applied the season the infraction is found:
Any playoff games: Full GM pay fine and loss of CW pass for the season.
Because the player in question played all 66 games for Regina S73 as well as playoff games, Regina's GMs will be fined full pay for the season and will forfeit their CW pass for next season. Also because the player in question was not properly paid a contract even though they were accounted for on the budget, Regina must submit the proper contract for the player to get what they were owed.
As always, the team is free to appeal this decision should they wish. We thank them for their cooperation in this issue. Should anyone have any questions, comments or concerns, please do not hesitate to reach out!
RE: REG Budget Violation - Skeleton Party - 12-07-2023
guillotine
RE: REG Budget Violation - Reno - 12-07-2023
I think this is a good example of why SHL teams should actually fucking talk to the SMJHL GMs instead of treating us like second class citizens.
RE: REG Budget Violation - Seany148 - 12-07-2023
i blame Hffo
RE: REG Budget Violation - Evok - 12-07-2023
At this point i feel we are playing a game of whack a mole, the easiest solution is to request contract links again for smjhl budget. and SHL gms should be more open with communication, when they drop players and who they resign, cause i feel like all those issues should be catch way earlier or like prevented more easily. It take a few seconds to send a message to a gm.
RE: REG Budget Violation - Reno - 12-07-2023
12-07-2023, 09:50 PMEvok Wrote: At this point i feel we are playing a game of whack a mole, the easiest solution is to request contract links again for smjhl budget. and SHL gms should be more open with communication, when they drop players and who they resign, cause i feel like all those issues should be catch way earlier or like prevented more easily. It take a few seconds to send a message to a gm.
It takes a few seconds - and yet it doesn't happen. Cause why would it.
RE: REG Budget Violation - Evok - 12-07-2023
12-07-2023, 10:02 PMReno Wrote: It takes a few seconds - and yet it doesn't happen. Cause why would it.
im 100% with you on this, but for now the best way to protect yourself as a gm is to gather the links yourself, we do it on qcc and it avoided us a lot of issue.
Wish things could get better with communication as well though
RE: REG Budget Violation - Seany148 - 12-07-2023
12-07-2023, 09:50 PMEvok Wrote: At this point i feel we are playing a game of whack a mole, the easiest solution is to request contract links again for smjhl budget. and SHL gms should be more open with communication, when they drop players and who they resign, cause i feel like all those issues should be catch way earlier or like prevented more easily. It take a few seconds to send a message to a gm.That's what we do here in
RE: REG Budget Violation - luke - 12-07-2023
12-07-2023, 09:22 PMReno Wrote: I think this is a good example of why SHL teams should actually fucking talk to the SMJHL GMs instead of treating us like second class citizens.
I hear the call ups and send downs there is a pretty good resource to look for your players. Or like you said, takes a couple seconds to dm the GM to see what happened
RE: REG Budget Violation - Reno - 12-07-2023
12-07-2023, 10:37 PMluke Wrote: I hear the call ups and send downs there is a pretty good resource to look for your players. Or like you said, takes a couple seconds to dm the GM to see what happened
Winnipeg never even made a post in the S73 Call Up/Send Down thread so great piece of advice there. I know that thread exists and I check it but if they quietly release him prior to that thread without any notification to me or anyone close to Regina it's hard to work with a lack of information since the portal stupidly lumps that info in with the update section.
RE: REG Budget Violation - Acsolap - 12-08-2023
12-07-2023, 11:48 PMReno Wrote: Winnipeg never even made a post in the S73 Call Up/Send Down thread so great piece of advice there. I know that thread exists and I check it but if they quietly release him prior to that thread without any notification to me or anyone close to Regina it's hard to work with a lack of information since the portal stupidly lumps that info in with the update section.
Why don't you communicate with the GM's of your players? I checked prior to start of off season with all the GM's of my players when I ran Anchorage for this exact reason. The woe is me attitude of a large number of the smjhl GM's is quite frankly laughable.
RE: REG Budget Violation - Evok - 12-08-2023
12-08-2023, 02:56 AMAcsolap Wrote: Why don't you communicate with the GM's of your players? I checked prior to start of off season with all the GM's of my players when I ran Anchorage for this exact reason. The woe is me attitude of a large number of the smjhl GM's is quite frankly laughable.
Not saying everyone is bad but even when we poke SHL GMs some frankly just looks like they wanna make you misserable and you have to pull their teeth out for information. We asked a GM this offseason about the possibility of early call up, which they had asked their players earlier. We were just told to go ask the player because the communication wasn't required from them. We made the first move. We were not asking them of warning us in the future, we were not asking to know all the littles moves planned in the future, we were asking about a specific situation related to a specific player. It would have been just as fast to provide the information asked which they probably had already, but for some reason didn't want to share when asked.
RE: REG Budget Violation - artermis - 12-08-2023
12-07-2023, 09:50 PMEvok Wrote: At this point i feel we are playing a game of whack a mole, the easiest solution is to request contract links again for smjhl budget. and SHL gms should be more open with communication, when they drop players and who they resign, cause i feel like all those issues should be catch way earlier or like prevented more easily. It take a few seconds to send a message to a gm.
Yeah, we we have been asked in the past to link contracts (Per ACAP message in the announcements channel on 09/05/2022) but it hasn't enforced or legitemately required I suppose.
I've linked contracts ever since in my budget, but that didn't save me from making this same mistake this past season, albeit it usually does.
12-07-2023, 10:37 PMluke Wrote: I hear the call ups and send downs there is a pretty good resource to look for your players. Or like you said, takes a couple seconds to dm the GM to see what happened
Some teams do not list players they drop, however you're right in those cases that follow-up is appropriate. What lead to myself committing the same offence last season was that the send-down thread was up the day before the SMJHL draft, and my follow-ups (which I usually conduct prior to the draft) were forgotten about.
RE: REG Budget Violation - Sburbine - 12-08-2023
I'm gonna start using @GM in SHL gen a lot more
RE: REG Budget Violation - Citizen of Adraa - 12-08-2023
12-08-2023, 05:40 AMEvok Wrote: Not saying everyone is bad but even when we poke SHL GMs some frankly just looks like they wanna make you misserable and you have to pull their teeth out for information. We asked a GM this offseason about the possibility of early call up, which they had asked their players earlier. We were just told to go ask the player because the communication wasn't required from them. We made the first move. We were not asking them of warning us in the future, we were not asking to know all the littles moves planned in the future, we were asking about a specific situation related to a specific player. It would have been just as fast to provide the information asked which they probably had already, but for some reason didn't want to share when asked.
I am not sure if this is something pertaining me, but I responded to a J GM this way...mostly because it was down to the J player themselves. If they made the call and wanted to go up, I would call them up. If they wanted to stay down and play their last season, they would stay down. I gave them the full control, therefore it was their decision and I didn't have the information necessary to respond, because it wasn't even my decision in the first place.