+- Simulation Hockey League (https://simulationhockey.com)
+-- Forum: Community (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=17)
+--- Forum: SHL Discussion (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=49)
+---- Forum: Suggestion Box (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=50)
+---- Thread: Fitness TPE option (/showthread.php?tid=141549)
Pages:
1
2
Fitness TPE option - No Goal - 02-20-2025
I have thought about this for quite awhile and would like to propose a fitness TPE option. As standing you can write, you can do art, or you can post you completed from affiliated league. I would like to present the 4th option of working out for TPE. This could be tracked by app, watch, or other fitness tracker and would encourage the league to go out and go to the gym, walk, run etc. I will be upfront the biggest concern is "cheating" the system but I have a few things here:
- A good chat gpt user (I have not looked personally) is hard if not impossible to catch because they can spend time modifying the post or refining the answer. AI detection is not effective despite what you have done in the past.
- AI art exists and while it has some tell tale signs the same can be said here if it is done the right way
- How well are other leagues vetting this vs. our league?
Week over week it would be possible to tell if someone is photo shopping or if they are cheating the fitness tracker but honestly it is cheating themselves if someone did that and cheaters are going to cheat no matter what you do.
Another concern I see is privacy which could be mitigated by blocking out details from a post or even a DM to a grader if that is the direction wanted.
Another concern I see is accessibility as I understand that not everyone is able to go on a walk or go to the gym etc. for whatever reason. The other paths to get the TPE would not go away nor would they change it would provide another option. To put it this way it is no different than I am not in the ISFL so I cannot use them to complete my SHL tasks. I am also not an artist so I would struggle to do the art options anyways. Some users can draw circles around me! More options are not a large problem.
Last one could be grading but if anything grading a picture would be easier than grading words that require reading.
The chart here could be flexible and the idea would be to promote health and wellness I also think it would make sense to be active provided we are a sports league (even if virtual or DND style)
- Could be limited to x times a month
- Not that it should but it could be on a straight honor system (Not in favor but it is an option) or some sort of picture could be required
- Could include different types of workouts such as running, walking, biking, or things like weights/elliptical sky is the limit
- Would provide more league options I think it would even provide more content and align the goal of leveling up the player with fitness
Never mentioned this here this is the first time I have seen this part of the forum but it is something I thought of before in the past. Open to feedback ideas and debate I want to make the league as best as it can be!
RE: Fitness TPE option - sve7en - 02-20-2025
Holy mother of God I never have to write again
RE: Fitness TPE option - TheOPSquid - 02-20-2025
getting extra tpe for hitting prs would be huge
RE: Fitness TPE option - Ruggsy - 02-20-2025
Fitness deez
RE: Fitness TPE option - RashfordU - 02-20-2025
Time to attach the fitness tracker to my 2 kids, I'm set
RE: Fitness TPE option - micool132 - 02-20-2025
Fitness deez
RE: Fitness TPE option - Frenchie - 02-20-2025
@Kalakar this is SHL walkscape pog
RE: Fitness TPE option - WannabeFinn - 02-20-2025
I’ve had the same thought. It’s not a bad idea. But…
Written media/PTs and graphics contribute to the league in a specific way. They are SHL specific, meaning they contribute to the history, lore, and understanding of our league, sport, and community at large.
Going for a jog does not contribute to our league in any meaningful way. Hitting a new record on the bench press doesn’t further the league. If anything, allowing players to earn money or TPE based on physical activities done outside of the purview of the league can only draw activity away from our community.
Again, it’s a nice idea. Who wouldn’t want to get healthier and also achieve some of their goals here? Unfortunately the two don’t seem to align in a practical way.
RE: Fitness TPE option - Reno - 02-20-2025
Sweating to the oldies but instead of the oldies its SHL Podcasts so we can tie it back to the league in some way.
RE: Fitness TPE option - Ashes - 02-20-2025
idk about tpe, but give me money for hitting 10k steps every day and i will surpass elon musk's wealth and buy twitter
RE: Fitness TPE option - HabsFanFromOntario - 02-20-2025
- A good chat gpt user (I have not looked personally) is hard if not impossible to catch because they can spend time modifying the post or refining the answer. AI detection is not effective despite what you have done in the past.
- AI art exists and while it has some tell tale signs the same can be said here if it is done the right way
- How well are other leagues vetting this vs. our league?
To these points, the amount of time somebody would take modifying an AI PT is about the same as doing a PT if not slightly more so congrats you just did the work anyways? AI art usually gets caught pretty quickly but I'm sure there will be more dangers for these as more advancements come out in the future. That said I would love more motivation to get in shape and it's a great idea. Maybe it could work towards the mPT or something
RE: Fitness TPE option - ThisSeemsFishy - 02-21-2025
Fitness? How bout fitness TPE in your build?
gottem
RE: Fitness TPE option - CampinKiller - 02-21-2025
02-20-2025, 03:26 PMWannabeFinn Wrote: I’ve had the same thought. It’s not a bad idea. But…
Written media/PTs and graphics contribute to the league in a specific way. They are SHL specific, meaning they contribute to the history, lore, and understanding of our league, sport, and community at large.
Going for a jog does not contribute to our league in any meaningful way. Hitting a new record on the bench press doesn’t further the league. If anything, allowing players to earn money or TPE based on physical activities done outside of the purview of the league can only draw activity away from our community.
Again, it’s a nice idea. Who wouldn’t want to get healthier and also achieve some of their goals here? Unfortunately the two don’t seem to align in a practical way.
Hitting a new bench PR clearly contributes to the longevity of the league by ensuring users are healthy and remain on the league for a long time, hello Lee? HO will not keep me from working out!!!!
RE: Fitness TPE option - Inf1d3l - 02-21-2025
I like the idea as SHL Bux for sure but maybe cap is seasonally to just maybe 2 mil or so? Something to earn a little extra for getting in shape but not a point where you can pay for literally everything and not have to involve yourself in the league still
RE: Fitness TPE option - caltroit_red_flames - 02-21-2025
I ain't coding that shit