+- Simulation Hockey League (https://simulationhockey.com)
+-- Forum: League Media (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=610)
+--- Forum: Graphics (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=52)
+---- Forum: Weekly Submissions (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=274)
+----- Forum: Graded Weekly Submissions (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=567)
+----- Thread: Rules + Grading System (/showthread.php?tid=8861)
- Corco - 06-11-2012
Since I'm the new GFX grader, I'll be implementing a new system, which gives you TPE rather than $$$.
Rules:
-Must submit two sigs for one week
-HALF OF THE TPE WILL BE UNCAPPED
-Cannot use the same sig twice
-Must be original (no copying)
-You must post a message saying "CLAIM" after I grade your GFX
Grading System:
Signature 1:
Effort: x/5
Look: x/5
Total: x/10
Signature 2:
Effort: x/5
Look: x/5
Total: x/10
PT Total: x/10
20 – 17.5 = 4 TPE (2 Capped, 2 Uncapped)
17 – 14.5 = 3 TPE (2 Capped, 1 Uncapped)
14 – 11.5 = 2 TPE (1 Capped, 1 Uncapped)
11 – 5.5 = 1 TPE (1 Capped)
5 – 0 = 0 TPE
Example:
![[Image: 881CCE88-CFA9-4210-8EE6-D5D9246E8456-614...4B98A9.jpg]](http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y88/Crashnburnluder/881CCE88-CFA9-4210-8EE6-D5D9246E8456-6146-00000390314B98A9.jpg)
Signature 1:
Effort: 5/5
Look: 5/5
Total: 10/10
![[Image: CharlieSerpeUSA.png]](http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y88/Crashnburnluder/CharlieSerpeUSA.png)
Signature 2:
Effort: 4/5
Look: 4/5
Total: 8/10
Total Grade:
18/20 = 4 TPE (2 Capped - 2 Uncapped)
Format:
Code:
[u][b]Signature #1[/b][/u]
[u]Effort:[/u]
[u]Look:[/u]
[b]Total:[/b]
[u][b]Signature #2[/b][/u]
[u]Effort:[/u]
[u]Look:[/u]
[b]Total:[/b]
[u][b]TOTAL:[/b][/u]
[u][b]TPE:[/b][/u]- BasedMinkus - 06-11-2012
can we post them now then?
- Corco - 06-11-2012
Quote:Originally posted by JayTee@Jun 11 2012, 02:51 PMYes. It is monday, the start of a new SHL week.
can we post them now then?
- grimreaper - 06-11-2012
Once you've reached your PT cap, are you still allowed to submit for the uncapped points?
- Corco - 06-11-2012
Quote:Originally posted by grimreaper@Jun 11 2012, 02:59 PMYes, that was why I included the Uncapped part. I didn't want people who had already hit their Cap to miss out.
Once you've reached your PT cap, are you still allowed to submit for the uncapped points?
- grimreaper - 06-11-2012
Quote:Originally posted by Corcoran@Jun 11 2012, 06:59 PM
Yes
Does that not sound slightly unbalanced to you? This will become a constant source of uncapped TPE for a handful of members.
- Corco - 06-11-2012
Quote:Originally posted by grimreaper@Jun 11 2012, 03:02 PMI'll grade extra hard
Does that not sound slightly unbalanced to you? This will become a constant source of uncapped TPE for a handful of members.
Or, I could reduce the number from x/6 to x/4.
- grimreaper - 06-11-2012
Quote:Originally posted by Corcoran@Jun 11 2012, 07:04 PM
I'll grade extra hard
I'm just saying it makes no sense. You don't get TPE for media articles, why should you for graphics? I'd propose to make it fair for those who dislike writing PTs, you offer a graphics PT that is worth the equivalent TPE for every writing PT that is posted. Otherwise this is a weekly PT with uncapped TPE that not every member is able to participate in.
- Corco - 06-11-2012
Quote:Originally posted by grimreaper@Jun 11 2012, 03:08 PMWell to be fair, I would actually prefer if we make a TPE scale for articles based on word count, but that is just my opinion. But, every system is going to have its kinks and stuff. btw, Spangle did give me the go-ahead on this
I'm just saying it makes no sense. You don't get TPE for media articles, why should you for graphics? I'd propose to make it fair for those who dislike writing PTs, you offer a graphics PT that is worth the equivalent TPE for every writing PT that is posted. Otherwise this is a weekly PT with uncapped TPE that not every member is able to participate in.
- grimreaper - 06-11-2012
Quote:Originally posted by Corcoran@Jun 11 2012, 07:12 PM
Well to be fair, I would actually prefer if we make a TPE scale for articles based on word count, but that is just my opinion. But, every system is going to have its kinks and stuff. btw, Spangle did give me the go-ahead on this
I just think it hasn't been thought through well enough. You can't give TPE for graphics and then not for articles.
- Spangle - 06-11-2012
Maybe just make it out of 2.
- Corco - 06-11-2012
Changed to x/4 scale
- Patches - 06-11-2012
what happened to all the other unpaid weeks??????
I also think PTE for GFX is unfair. should stay a cash reward, like articles.
- Tylar - 06-11-2012
Quote:Originally posted by Patrick80@Jun 11 2012, 03:17 PM
what happened to all the other unpaid weeks??????
I also think PTE for GFX is unfair. should stay a cash reward, like articles.
How is that fair? So if you can't do graphics then your screwed... Should make one for articles then.
- Corco - 06-11-2012
Quote:Originally posted by Tylar@Jun 11 2012, 05:16 PMThat's what I'm saying
How is that fair? So if you can't do graphics then your screwed... Should make one for articles then.