if i HAD to rank…

1. Montana
2. Elway
3. Brady
4. Manning
5. Marino

Originally posted by Midas Whale@Dec 28 2014, 12:53 PM

bottom line is they never get it done when it matters.

i know KC is a hard place to win, but holy shit.
you're playing against Chase Daniel in a must win game

But they didn't lose to Chase Daniel. They lost because the Chiefs have good D.

Originally posted by JayTee@Dec 28 2014, 03:54 PM


Well ya, Brady nut huggers always see him as top 3.

It is quite cute.

Edit whoops I think I'm actually wrong there. Disregard

Thank you to My boys @Merica and @Ragnar for the lovely sigs!

Originally posted by JayTee@Dec 28 2014, 03:56 PM


But they didn't lose to Chase Daniel.  They lost because the Chiefs have good D.

true, but the Chargers are supposed to have a good O

Originally posted by Midas Whale@Dec 28 2014, 03:55 PM
if i HAD to rank…

1. Montana
2. Elway
3. Brady
4. Manning
5. Marino

Yeah I'd agree.

Thank you to My boys @Merica and @Ragnar for the lovely sigs!

Originally posted by Maxy@Dec 28 2014, 03:58 PM

Yeah I'd agree.

if Brady wins another SB tho, id put him ahead of Elway and 1b. with Montana

Originally posted by Midas Whale@Dec 28 2014, 12:58 PM

true, but the Chargers are supposed to have a good O

Yes but Rivers has like a fucked up back and looks like it.


Also wins are a team stat maxy.

Originally posted by JayTee@Dec 28 2014, 04:00 PM


Yes but Rivers has like a fucked up back and looks like it.


Also wins are a team stat maxy.

Well Peyton's a pretty shitty team player then givin his playoff record :lol:

Thank you to My boys @Merica and @Ragnar for the lovely sigs!

Originally posted by JayTee@Dec 28 2014, 01:46 PM


:-> <--- this indicates a joke.

God the SHL is so sensitive.


also

A. Luck 10/16 160 10.0 2 0 1-1 135.4

WHAT A SHITTY DAY.

But remember, yardage is all that matters in the MVP race haha

LA Panthers Goaltender

Originally posted by Midas Whale@Dec 28 2014, 04:00 PM

if Brady wins another SB tho, id put him ahead of Elway and 1b. with Montana

It'd be hard not to. He's already won more playoff games than any other QB in history, one more ring would put him right up there. I think I'd put him at #2 but I could see the argument for 1A and 1B

Thank you to My boys @Merica and @Ragnar for the lovely sigs!

Originally posted by Maxy@Dec 28 2014, 01:01 PM

Well Peyton's a pretty shitty team player then givin his playoff record :lol:

He couldn't help that those Colts teams were bad in pretty much every respect.

as far as the MVP race goes, id give it to Rodgers.

if it was more like the Heisman and supposed to go to simply the "best" player, id give it JJ Watt.
but i don't see Watt being more "valuable" than Rodgers.


if the Texans traded Watt for Rodgers, they'd be a better team
and if the Packers traded Rodgers for Watt, they'd be a worse team
imo

Originally posted by C.J.@Dec 28 2014, 01:02 PM

But remember, yardage is all that matters in the MVP race haha

Haha ya.

oh wait no TDs as well.

Originally posted by JayTee@Dec 28 2014, 04:04 PM


He couldn't help that those Colts teams were bad in pretty much every respect.

they're defense was bad, but they were stacked on the offensive side of the ball.
o-line was always good, Harrison, Wayne, Stokely, Edgerrin James, etc

Peyton also had a lot of choke moments in big playoff games tbh

Originally posted by Midas Whale@Dec 28 2014, 04:05 PM
as far as the MVP race goes, id give it to Rodgers.

if it was more like the Heisman and supposed to go to simply the "best" player, id give it JJ Watt.
but i don't see Watt being more "valuable" than Rodgers.


if the Texans traded Watt for Rodgers, they'd be a better team
and if the Packers traded Rodgers for Watt, they'd be a worse team
imo

Well yeah it's hard to go off of the MVP race especially when it's a QB and a LB, mainly because if you don't have a starting QB that's quality, you get... Well the Texans. I can say that if the Texans didn't have Watt, I'd be willing to bet that they'd be about where they were last year.

Thank you to My boys @Merica and @Ragnar for the lovely sigs!