Login

*AgentSmith630* · 05-07-2022, 12:49 AM

05-06-2022, 11:22 PMYagoyi Wrote:
05-06-2022, 11:14 PMAgentSmith630 Wrote: Imagine only looking at 6 stats when deciding who should be nommed for any award, let alone RotY. C'mon man

so what's your argument for Hale?

I'm not on the awards committee, so I don't have one. I'm just saying that only comparing players based on 6 stats when there are so many others, especially relevant others, is a bit off.

Yagoyi · 05-07-2022, 01:27 AM

05-07-2022, 12:49 AMAgentSmith630 Wrote:
05-06-2022, 11:22 PMYagoyi Wrote: so what's your argument for Hale?

I'm not on the awards committee, so I don't have one. I'm just saying that only comparing players based on 6 stats when there are so many others, especially relevant others, is a bit off.

Kentaro Kikuchi - Shots blocked: 45, PDO: 99.1, GF/60: 3.2, GA/60: 2.5, SF/60: 41.3, SA/60: 28.6, CF%: 60.3, CF% rel: -0.6, FF%: 60, FF% rel: 0.2

Atticus Hale - Shots blocked: 5, PDO: 98.4, GF/60: 2.7, GA/60: 3.6, SF/60: 33.3, SA/60: 36.8. CF%: 47.2, CF% rel: -3.5, FF% 47, FF% rel: -3.4

Do you think +/- is relevant? Kikuchi beats Hale in that too.

Is 16 stats enough? Or does Hale deserve it purely on giveaways/takeaways, because that's all he has on Kikuchi.

Yagoyi · 05-07-2022, 01:49 AM

05-06-2022, 11:12 PMToast Wrote:
05-06-2022, 09:28 PMYagoyi Wrote: Kentaro Kikuchi: 22G, 28A, 50P, 14 PIM, 91 HIT, 61 GR

Atticus Hale: 16G, 25A, 41P, 24 PIM, 43 HIT, 59 GR

what a joke. I guess its time to recreate

Kentaro Kikuchi: 18:56 ATOI / 1:30 minutes PP, 9 PP points

Atticus Haloe: 17:30 ATOI / 0:47 minutes PP, 3 PP points

enjoy retirement

Kentaro Kikuchi - Shots blocked: 45, PDO: 99.1, GF/60: 3.2, GA/60: 2.5, SF/60: 41.3, SA/60: 28.6, CF%: 60.3, CF% rel: -0.6, FF%: 60, FF% rel: 0.2

Atticus Hale - Shots blocked: 5, PDO: 98.4, GF/60: 2.7, GA/60: 3.6, SF/60: 33.3, SA/60: 36.8. CF%: 47.2, CF% rel: -3.5, FF% 47, FF% rel: -3.4

Replying to you too since you wanna be an ass about it. I'm sure the additional 1:26 ATOI made all the difference here...

Ronniewalker · 05-07-2022, 03:13 AM

Smh. No Kikuchi, no Kondos!? So having a true rookie actually succeed on a top line without being a liability instead is somehow a completely unspectacular feat in this league? Eyebrow

At least Yagoyi got the deserved manager and coach noms.

Sigs by sulovilen , Ragnar , supertardis101 , Leviadan , High Stick King , Carpy & KaleSalad

S69 Challenge Cup Champion - Philadelphia Forge Forge

S59 & S62 Challenge Cup Champion - Texas Renegades

S57 Four Star Cup Champion - Anchorage Armada Armada

S57 & S58 WJC / S62, S64 & S66 IIHF Gold Medalist - Team Finland Finland

After 69 shots on net with still no SHL goals to show for it, even the opposition started to feel so sorry for Lemo, that they decided to help him out :D

- Bad pass by Jack Klompus, he gave it right to Lemo Pihl.

- Lemo Pihl rips it to the net...

- Lemo Pihl will find the empty net, that should do it!

TEX @ MAN, S59 game 31

**RomanesEuntDomus** · 05-07-2022, 05:38 AM

@Yagoyi I get your frustration, it was a very close vote and I actually pushed for Kikuchi quite a bit in the last round of the nomination process but was ultimately outvoted. I think the main argument against your player for the other voters was indeed the additional ice time you got, especially on the Powerplay, as well as the very bad takeaway-giveaway ratio. Some voters seem to be very sensitive in regards to GMs playing their own players a lot after some examples of that in the past, which might have worked against you here. I don't really agree with that, just trying to show you what some of the internal arguments were that lead to this decision. And it ultimately came down to a tiebreaker, so it was very close nontheless.