Sig 1: 6/10 = 600k
Theres a lot going on in this sig. The text work and the little details done are very nice. The added text and the little "story line" style of signature is very nice to see and creative. The signature of Lukes player and the added squares to give me focus is very nice. And I also noticed the added jersey change. The only thing is, its a very basic sig other than that. And the one thing that bothered me was that the render didnt resize in a relative way. Its kind of squished and it makes it low quality. Always make sure the render stays the same throughout. When resizing, hold down shift when pulling from the corners or make sure the checkmark "Keep Relative Sizing" is on.

Sig 2: 6/10 = 600k
I also gave this sig/player card a 6 because of the little things that bothered me. The main one is, the render is super low quality. Its like weirdly blurred and Its hard for me to focus on the face because it seems really bad quality. Also, you made this nice player card but so much of the space is wasted with the trim/border of the white. Its a lot of wasted space for something so big. You could have either made the sides smaller or you could have filled it up more

TOTAL = 1.2MIL