Sig 1: 9/10 - 950K
Great use of color, lighting, depth, and shadow.

Sig 2: 8/10 - 825K
good colors and text, and good way of introducing the colors in an interesting way.

Sig 3: 8/10 - 825K
good dynamic lighting. the round flare/lines are a clever way of introducing the secondary color in this semi monochromatic piece.

Sig 4: 7/10 - 700K
I really like the jersey recoloring, and the player's lighting is great, but it doesn't match the smoke or the flatter background.

Total = 3.3M