Great article!
I think Drayson Williams is probably the biggest first overall pick bust ever, unless something happened while I was gone. I joined like a third of the way through Season 2 and I'm pretty sure he was already inactive by that point lol.
Jarmuth and Singh were members who I recognize from the VHL, and I'm pretty sure both of them have made hall of fame players (or at least very good players) over there.
Taldon Shepard was LX_Theo's player, who was NWJHL (SMJHL) commissioner early on so it was a good pick at the time. I remember him being very active for a couple seasons but he went inactive (idk when) so that probably explains his lack of success.