09-23-2020, 03:22 PMjfisherr Wrote:

09-23-2020, 03:00 PMhonkerrs Wrote: Great wording and suggestions fish.  Exactly why I didn't want to propose any changes because I'm not good at wording things but I think you outlined some great possibilities. I agree with @Ragnartoo that we need a position tracker honestly.  Most other leagues have it, so why shouldn't we??

 I will agree that it players could take advantage of this situation in the draft but personally I think it is worth it still.  In other leagues you can swap from like Relief Pitcher to Starter and vice versa.  Maybe no one can swap to goalie but goalies can swap to skaters sort of thing.  Anyways, hope smart people take the data and make some rules =]

Yeah of course, I just think GMs will pushback as they could have a plan for the future in place that could get blown up by a goalie wanting to position switch. This acts as a compromise between allowing no switches and allowing mass switches. However, if GMs have no concerns about this, then let’s just allow free position changes for all goalies in the SMJHL.

Maybe first pass through when this is implemented you have to have both GM and Player sign off on the swap to happen.  So if a GM really views the goalie as essential it wouldn't screw their vision.  Honestly anything allowing me to swap I'm gonna basically be down for because I see no upside to myself sticking to a goalie at the moment other than I just spent time building him so might as well keep going for "fun".