11-26-2020, 08:10 PMMike Izzy Wrote:

11-26-2020, 07:46 PMslothfacekilla Wrote:

I mean Kimmy/Sloth.. there have been 1000 post award discussions about methadology.. this isnt anything new...listen Tates a great goalie, deserving of great accolades! he was simply awesome this year! i made sure in my OP i said just that... but i think this is a fair discussion topic because in the past those meat and potato stats which were vital in the award outcome were heavily considered and the advanced stats were used peripherally to determine a winner of 2 players close in statistics..  that doesnt seem to be the methadology here in this award as the meat and potato stats seemed to have become devalued without that being addressed in public. .. So there's a new criteria which im hoping would be clarified here in this post. (in a nice and respectful way please)  so maybe no ones scratching there heads in the future and we dont have to have this discussion for the next time around. ya know?

Kimmy... Kata is a friend, but im also his GM and id make a clarification post for any of my players...i would hope that your GM's now or in the future do the same for you if they felt an answer was helpful/needed.


If there is a advanced stats comparison available ... that would be helpful and maybe help move along this inquiry   

I think a big issue that they're pointing out is like duff said. It simply takes the wind out of the winners sail. I'm not here to defend my player winning or if they were deserving of the award or not because there are a lot of great goalies who could have won this and it could have 100% went a different way. However, I think making a public post complaining about the methodology while also shitting all over the winner because you feel your own team's player performed better is unfair to the winner of the award. Simply go to the awards committee and ask them their methodology behind why they chose Booth over Vilde and see if they can provide stats instead of making a giant deal out of it on the forums where the winner can see and feel deflated because immediately after a win it's brought into question. I'm sure the awards committee would be more than happy to answer all of these questions had you PMed them.