11-26-2020, 09:52 PMWally Wrote:

11-26-2020, 09:48 PMDuff101 Wrote: This is such a poor argument though because you’re asking for data that nobody has. We don’t even know if FHM has a shot quality index and for all we know every shot could be weighted equally in the eyes of FHM. If you wanna dig through every game and rate shots based on quality be my guest, but until then asking people to evaluate goalies based on stats that don’t exist is not possible.

Also I second RED here I just didn’t wanna double post

No that isn’t poor at all. You have no clue in your mind where any shots come from. The slot, uncontested, from the point... we have no data that is my point exactly. We have not one true advanced stat. So we keep using the inflated metrics with no meat or basis of validity to what a goalie actually faces.

In that case isnt literally every stat invalid? You could make the argument that SV% is an invalid stat because we don’t know shot quality and at that point what do we do.

also lets ignore there are plenty of advanced stats like GSAA that don’t use shot quality as a metric at all