A Maine Timber battle royale would be a rough one. Maine, being a rather ascetic place with lots of nature, tends to draw people who aren't afraid of being physical. However, there are some guys that would have a clear advantage.

The biggest favourite I'd say would be Bigga Foryu. Simply because he's huge. I don't know if anyone could really compete with him. Some sneaky picks could be Fredrik "El Profesor" Stefansson and Dogwood Maple. They are guys who have extremely high IQ on and off the ice, and you can never guess their next moves. Another real dark horse could be Puddles O'Duck. I mean, how do you even fight a duck? He's probably very slipper and with his gift of flight he could be impossible to catch. O'Duck could just fly away everytime someone was about to cacth him, and eventually drain their stamina. One more candidate could be Jonny Tsunami. He seems flat out crazy, and would probably be quite the fighter.