If I ever recreate I will probably be building a more offensively minded forward as opposed to a two way one, so an award I could win is the Gabe Johnson award which is given to players who excel offensively but are absolutely atrocious and lazy in their own end of the ice, so it's like the opposite of the Dar trophy. Winners of this award will usually be near the top of the league in points, shots and goals. These players won't necessarily commit a lot of giveaways but because they never backcheck, they will have close to 0 takeaways and thus a terrible ga/ta ratio so that's one quick way to identify the potential nominees for this award. their +/- will be around 0 because Gabe Johnson award winners generate just enough offense to make up for their bad defense, but if someone manages to score a lot and still end up with a terrible +/-, they'd be the favorite to win most seasons.