It’s still an illegal trade. There shouldn’t be any retention on Sheppard but there is. But the punishment for retaining it is a 3rd?
I get where HO is coming from but it’s an illegal trade straight from a rulebook. Make them renegotiate.

Especially since if it was caught before approval they would have had to renegotiate. So now the precedent is if they retained, it wasn’t caught, and it’s too “late” for a reversal it stands.