I think of this award in a different manner than others have posted. Coveted is most sought after - people in year 4 have to move onto the SHL league and while they may be sought after in that league they are already drafted a few seasons ago. I would nominate as follows:   (I will briefly say myself BUT I think the others listed below are quite frankly more sought after so in the interest of this post I will focus on the 2 below) 

Alexa Johansen - SMHJL intern. One of the most active and helpful rookies in S76. Alexa will go far as long as they continue to be active and open. Someone I want to have on my team. 

MattyJ - Another very active and determined rookie. MattyJ is a rival and friend of mine on the server. He is someone that I would like to have on my team. 

These rookies have a bright future in the junior league and other teams should do what they can to trade for them if able. Having a high score is great but if you are leaving the league then it would make you less sought after due to the rules of the game -  what made me look into rookies is the future and the word coveted.