Puddles would definitely win the entire show. He has a strong brain and strong muscles. He may struggle with some of the eating tasks, but honestly I don’t think those would be a problem either. He’s used to eating worms and dirty water, and most of the eating challenges are gross things to humans. But gross things to humans aren’t gross to ducks. As far as the strength and physical ones go, I’m not sure of a task that a 6 foot 9, 269 pound physical specimen who can fly wouldn’t dominate. Mental would be east too. I’m a professional athlete that has to calculate dozens of movements and thoughts each second of the game. The hardest part would be not showing off too much in the challenges, otherwise I might voted off out of jealousy or fear. To combat that I will have to use my charm that I’ve always had since I was a mascot.