Originally posted by GCool@Oct 28 2015, 09:04 PM


BUT EVERY PLAYER IS THE SAMEEEEEEEE :((

I laughed. +1

GoB's Writing Thread

Originally posted by GCool@Oct 28 2015, 06:04 PM


BUT EVERY PLAYER IS THE SAMEEEEEEEE :((



Then can you explain the Ignant thing? Cuz as thrilled as I am for Portland, I don't get it.

He's the Connor McDavid of the league and will put up impressive numbers.

Cameron Carter II || LW/C || HOF INDUCTEE (via cuddles)
Projected Career TPE: 500-900
Number: #9, #4, #8
S45 IIHF Silver Medal, S48 IIHF Silver Medal, S50 IIHF Gold Medal
S46: 24 Goals (T-9), 192 Hits (4th)



Cole Carter || Örebro HK Youth || LW
Youth Player

Gonna be the buzzkill and assume that's where jalopski was supposed to be.

Originally posted by Boomcheck+Oct 28 2015, 08:16 PM--><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1' id='QUOTE-WRAP'><tr><td>QUOTE (Boomcheck @ Oct 28 2015, 08:16 PM)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'><!--QuoteEBegin-->

He's the Connor McDavid of the league and will put up impressive numbers.[/b]

Can you go back to not talking?

<!--QuoteBegin-Bojo@Oct 28 2015, 08:34 PM
Gonna be the buzzkill and assume that's where jalopski was supposed to be.[/quote]

Figured as much. Thanks though.

Originally posted by GCool@Oct 28 2015, 09:44 PM
Figured as much. Thanks though.

funny enough i didn't even think about your player's name when I said that. lol

A thing I see here is that there was some discrepancies between how I rated people and how the other judges did.

For example

In my ratings, Brian Morley and Darian Scherbluk were still 'generational' or 10/10 players, as I considered the body of work, not just the last season. A crappy first half of the season for Morley , to me, doesn't mean he's now a bad player, just that he had a tough start or some bad chemistry, but, clearly, he's still a high TPE and very good player.

Whereas some people, gonna throw Leo and DMoushey here as examples, 1 good season does not make you a 'consistent elite superstar' so I rated them clearly significantly lower than some of the other judges. Scherbluk and Morley are, to me, still generational talents because nobody as of yet has stepped up to knock them off that pedestal, and one season of less than stellar stats does not take that away from them. Clearly other people feel differently, seeing how far these two guys dropped after last season. Doesn't make them wrong, doesn't make me wrong, it's just a different approach to how one rates somebody!

Anyway, this is always fun and a neat thing and it's just some people's opinions, not the be all and end all of everything, but overall I feel the final rankings are, more or less, legit.

      S76 SMJHL DRAFT 3RD OVERALL PICK     
        S77 SHL DRAFT 4TH OVERALL PICK         
                     IIHF TEAM NORWAY                      

Originally posted by KezKincaid@Oct 28 2015, 11:03 PM
A thing I see here is that there was some discrepancies between how I rated people and how the other judges did.

For example

In my ratings, Brian&nbsp; Morley and Darian Scherbluk were still 'generational' or 10/10 players, as I considered the body of work, not just the last season. A crappy first half of the season for Morley , to me, doesn't mean he's now a bad player, just that he had a tough start or some bad chemistry, but, clearly, he's still a high TPE and very good player.

Whereas some people, gonna throw Leo and DMoushey here as examples, 1 good season does not make you a 'consistent elite superstar' so I rated them clearly significantly lower than some of the other judges. Scherbluk and Morley are, to me, still generational talents because nobody as of yet has stepped up to knock them off that pedestal, and one season of less than stellar stats does not take that away from them. Clearly other people feel differently, seeing how far these two guys dropped after last season. Doesn't make them wrong, doesn't make me wrong, it's just a different approach to how one rates somebody!

Anyway, this is always fun and a neat thing and it's just some people's opinions, not the be all and end all of everything, but overall I feel the final rankings are, more or less, legit.

i feel like that's reasonable but i think it should be largely based on S25 since its S25 rankings.. but definitely a player's general reputation over past seasons needs to be taken into account

I didn't see my name on list. Underrated as usual. )

Only 5th?!?!?!?

Snubbed

Originally posted by Shevy Shev@Oct 29 2015, 04:29 AM
Only 5th?!?!?!?

Snubbed

Better than Brojled.

:lol:

---

             

               

---

I don't care... this has entertained the hell out me for days now.

:ahh!:

---

             

               

---

Brojled is the only player that MAYBE should have been ahead of Ignant

Originally posted by Shevy Shev@Oct 29 2015, 12:48 AM
Brojled is the only player that MAYBE should have been ahead of Ignant

please replace that avy with a bartolo colon avy

Originally posted by Shevy Shev@Oct 29 2015, 04:48 AM
Brojled is the only player that MAYBE should have been ahead of Ignant

You're right. Brojled scored a Hat trick in the prospect show case. Brojled (only slightly)> Ignant

---

             

               

---

Originally posted by GCool@Oct 28 2015, 06:44 PM


Can you go back to not talking?

Loosen up some.

Cameron Carter II || LW/C || HOF INDUCTEE (via cuddles)
Projected Career TPE: 500-900
Number: #9, #4, #8
S45 IIHF Silver Medal, S48 IIHF Silver Medal, S50 IIHF Gold Medal
S46: 24 Goals (T-9), 192 Hits (4th)



Cole Carter || Örebro HK Youth || LW
Youth Player