Login

Segi · 01-08-2019, 03:51 PM

Alright, I'm going through the whole thread again and try to write down my thoughts to everyone. Keep in mind, I have never played a game like this with anyone of you, so I can't say if something is in character or not.

@Mack - his first comment was a vote against stamkosfan. votes for stamkosfan again. also says, the escort should reveal herself. (likely executioner with stamkos as a target or a jester.)

@Ace - very quiet. mentions late that we don't have much info. (either a wolf or has an important town role)

@"luketd" - agrees with no early lynchings (hasn't acted suspicious)

@TheWoZy - said he was suspicious of ml, because ml said normally no one gets lynched on the first day. is suspicious of kimmy. (is throwing suspicions here and there. jester?)

@Dangles13 - is the first to say not to hang anyone on the first day, but later kinda agrees with RED. wants to make the hidden escort play sound less appealing. (might be wolf)

@"AtlasHunter" - sends cryptic messages towards alaska. doesn't try to defend himself while standing at 2 votes. (possibly jester, could also be turncoat)

@Segi - obviously the smartest player. must be mayor or doctor or smth.

@39alaska39 - don't really have anything on him. Could be wolf if Atlas turns out to be jester.

@Good_Ole_Kimmy - pretty quiet over all. votes luketd. (might be wolf - hasn't explained his vote)

@BRayne - speaks out against day one lynches. (very quiet. might have an important role)

@Troy_McClure03 - was the first to ask Mack for a reason for his early vote. Tries to get lurkers talking. is the first to vote against AtlasHunter. (hasn't explained his vote. wasn't suspicious before that.)

@RomanesEuntDomus - joins late. speaks out for random lynchings. votes against kimmy. says the escort should stay hidden and not reveal the alphawolf. (I disagree on random lynchings, but he still might be a villager.)

@ml002 - pretty quiet. suspicious of pushers of early lynchings. (probably town)

@StamkosFan - started the game whith stating he might be a noob to this. Might be to distract from himself, but honestly I don't think this was too suspicious. Did get pretty quiet after geting voted. (likely town. maybe executioner's target)

@JKortesi81 - consistently against early lynching. made the first post like this one. presses people for the reasons for their votes. (likely town)

@Sleepy - votes for BadWolf probably as a joke. (pretty quiet. could be wolf)

@"TommySalami" - talks about everything but the game early on. talks about possible wolf strategies. is the second player to vote against AtlasHunter but later rescinds his vote (apparently not because of jester scare, but to see reactions of other players.) votes for Mack on day 2. (kinda suspicious, but I liked the play with the rescinded vote. I think, he's town.)

@BadWolf - talks a lot also tries to engage quiet players. (might be everything, I have no idea.)

***luke*** · 01-08-2019, 03:54 PM

I like that kimmy still has the updater tag on him

***BadWolf*** · 01-08-2019, 04:16 PM

Awesome recap segi. Just to clarify. I am all.

Durden · 01-08-2019, 04:24 PM

Current Votes:

StamkosFan - 1 (Mack)

Mack - 1 (Tommy)

***BadWolf*** · 01-08-2019, 04:31 PM

smh so maybe mack knows something?

***JKortesi81*** · 01-08-2019, 04:32 PM

01-08-2019, 04:24 PMDurden Wrote: Current Votes:

StamkosFan - 1 (Mack)

I believe Tommy voted for Mack too

Dangles13 · 01-08-2019, 04:35 PM

Suspicious

Mack - Not sure how to read him but right now I don't trust him.
luketd - Hasn't really helped and I have a gut feeling about him.
Segi - He appears to be hiding behind inexperience but is very smart and totally the Alpha
StamkosFan - Him and Mack are both wolves trying to pit us against them, probably, but maybe not.
BadWolf - Turncoat

Unsure - Wild-cards

TheWoZy - Wozman is a weird player who just throws out semi-accurate accusations and dips.
AtlasHunter - Weird dude and terrible goalie.
Ace - He should be a little more talkative imo but he hasn't done anything to warrant suspicion.
BRayne - Pretty quiet.
JKortesi81 - Could be good but Joe is mean sometimes. Wink

Sleepy - Been quiet
TommySalami - Salami should attract wolves and should be sent away from the village.

Safe

Dangles13 - Vanilla villager who will be eaten by day 3.
39alaska39 - Seems Legit
Good_Ole_Kimmy - Kimmy a good wolf
Troy_McClure03 - Could go either way tbh
RomanesEuntDomus - Veteran player and someone we should listen to his opinions.
ml002 - How could he be a wolf, really?

***BadWolf*** · 01-08-2019, 04:35 PM

Im leary about people throwing out votes

***BadWolf*** · 01-08-2019, 04:38 PM

01-08-2019, 04:35 PMDangles13 Wrote: Suspicious

Mack - Not sure how to read him but right now I don't trust him.
luketd - Hasn't really helped and I have a gut feeling about him.
Segi - He appears to be hiding behind inexperience but is very smart and totally the Alpha
StamkosFan - Him and Mack are both wolves trying to pit us against them, probably, but maybe not.
BadWolf - Turncoat

Unsure - Wild-cards

TheWoZy - Wozman is a weird player who just throws out semi-accurate accusations and dips.
AtlasHunter - Weird dude and terrible goalie.
Ace - He should be a little more talkative imo but he hasn't done anything to warrant suspicion.
BRayne - Pretty quiet.
JKortesi81 - Could be good but Joe is mean sometimes.
Sleepy - Been quiet
TommySalami - Salami should attract wolves and should be sent away from the village.

Safe

Dangles13 - Vanilla villager who will be eaten by day 3.
39alaska39 - Seems Legit
Good_Ole_Kimmy - Kimmy a good wolf
Troy_McClure03 - Could go either way tbh
RomanesEuntDomus - Veteran player and someone we should listen to his opinions.
ml002 - How could he be a wolf, really?

I dont think stammer is a wolf but I dont trust mack

Dangles13 · 01-08-2019, 04:39 PM

01-08-2019, 04:38 PMBadWolf Wrote: I dont think stammer is a wolf but I dont trust mack

That was just a little joke for the cheap seats.

***BadWolf*** · 01-08-2019, 04:44 PM

01-08-2019, 04:39 PMDangles13 Wrote:
01-08-2019, 04:38 PMBadWolf Wrote: I dont think stammer is a wolf but I dont trust mack

That was just a little joke for the cheap seats.

Ahh well I am frugal

Mack · 01-08-2019, 04:51 PM

I am 100% in favor of the Alpha wolf being named. I think the fact that someone guessed it so early could really help us. As I said before we could look at their posts and the replies to them to get an idea and they wouldn't have expected to get found out so fast.

Stamkos has played a variation of this game before and he knows that people who don't speak a lot at the start are thought to be wolves so he comes and tries to act like the best friendly townsfolk by posting 3 times in 15 minutes. Saying that wolves are usually quiet and we need to not be passive and such. He is a smart guy. He later plays the "I am just a noob sorry guys" card. Lots of people deflect from him as well.

@Dangles13 I like your breakdown you just posted except that you suspect me. I just voted Stamkos day 1 based on a good gut feeling and I feel like after all the replies there is no reason to not still suspect him. I voted early to get the game rolling because I am here to have fun.