Login

***Chevy*** · 03-31-2020, 04:50 PM

03-31-2020, 04:46 PMMutedfaith Wrote:
03-31-2020, 04:40 PMjfisherr Wrote: I would like to know why we shouldn’t be voting Durden over Muted atm. Durden began this whole master plan, and has often been the person we have followed and gathered most of our information the whole time. We know for a fact his information on the alpha was wrong, as Gekusoid pointed out. Perhaps Muted is the TC, he would know that Durden is a WW and is just playing the fuck out of us.

Let’s say Tommy is WW, him killing Vanilla Tron over Muted/Durden/trying to kill Doc makes zero fucking sense, unless Muted/Durden are a team.

Perhaps I’m overthinking this all. Maybe the WWs decided to attack one of their own in Durden in night 3 to give credibility to his escort claim knowing that the doc would likely save Durden.

Someone tell me I’m crazy? Idk
1. How would they know the doctor would save him?
2. They were already down to 3 wolves. You don't kill 1/3 of your team for 'credibility'

How do we know 'for a fact' that the alpha claim was wrong? Because that flavour text couldve meant anything.

Although in theory the alpha claim could be wrong. And nhamlet couldve been the alpha, with TommySalami and/or Grum the 3rd/4rd wolf.

That would mean the wolves did skip a night kill because they knew someone would be escorted and wanted to try and trick us. However, given that all the other roles and claims have been vetted, this changes nothing. Au contraire, it might mean that we were wrong about TommySalami, and that once we lynch Grum, its game over for the wolves.

Wolves have never killed one of their own. Both werewolves have been lynched (Segi / Nhamlet)

TnlAstatine · 03-31-2020, 04:50 PM

03-31-2020, 04:40 PMjfisherr Wrote: I would like to know why we shouldn’t be voting Durden over Muted atm. Durden began this whole master plan, and has often been the person we have followed and gathered most of our information the whole time. We know for a fact his information on the alpha was wrong, as Gekusoid pointed out. Perhaps Muted is the TC, he would know that Durden is a WW and is just playing the fuck out of us.

Let’s say Tommy is WW, him killing Vanilla Tron over Muted/Durden/trying to kill Doc makes zero fucking sense, unless Muted/Durden are a team.

Perhaps I’m overthinking this all. Maybe the WWs decided to attack one of their own in Durden in night 3 to give credibility to his escort claim knowing that the doc would likely save Durden.

Someone tell me I’m crazy? Idk

i'll vote either one of them, whoever gets the more people

*fishy* · 03-31-2020, 04:51 PM

03-31-2020, 04:46 PMMutedfaith Wrote:
03-31-2020, 04:40 PMjfisherr Wrote: I would like to know why we shouldn’t be voting Durden over Muted atm. Durden began this whole master plan, and has often been the person we have followed and gathered most of our information the whole time. We know for a fact his information on the alpha was wrong, as Gekusoid pointed out. Perhaps Muted is the TC, he would know that Durden is a WW and is just playing the fuck out of us.

Let’s say Tommy is WW, him killing Vanilla Tron over Muted/Durden/trying to kill Doc makes zero fucking sense, unless Muted/Durden are a team.

Perhaps I’m overthinking this all. Maybe the WWs decided to attack one of their own in Durden in night 3 to give credibility to his escort claim knowing that the doc would likely save Durden.

Someone tell me I’m crazy? Idk
1. How would they know the doctor would save him?
2. They were already down to 3 wolves. You don't kill 1/3 of your team for 'credibility'

How do we know 'for a fact' that the alpha claim was wrong? Because that flavour text couldve meant anything.

Although in theory the alpha claim could be wrong. And nhamlet couldve been the alpha, with TommySalami and/or Grum the 3rd/4rd wolf.

That would mean the wolves did skip a night kill because they knew someone would be escorted and wanted to try and trick us. However, given that all the other roles and claims have been vetted, this changes nothing. Au contraire, it might mean that once we lynch Grum, its game over for the wolves.

Why would we not lynch Tommy over Grum

TnlAstatine · 03-31-2020, 04:51 PM

03-31-2020, 04:46 PMMutedfaith Wrote:
03-31-2020, 04:40 PMjfisherr Wrote: I would like to know why we shouldn’t be voting Durden over Muted atm. Durden began this whole master plan, and has often been the person we have followed and gathered most of our information the whole time. We know for a fact his information on the alpha was wrong, as Gekusoid pointed out. Perhaps Muted is the TC, he would know that Durden is a WW and is just playing the fuck out of us.

Let’s say Tommy is WW, him killing Vanilla Tron over Muted/Durden/trying to kill Doc makes zero fucking sense, unless Muted/Durden are a team.

Perhaps I’m overthinking this all. Maybe the WWs decided to attack one of their own in Durden in night 3 to give credibility to his escort claim knowing that the doc would likely save Durden.

Someone tell me I’m crazy? Idk
1. How would they know the doctor would save him?
2. They were already down to 3 wolves. You don't kill 1/3 of your team for 'credibility'

How do we know 'for a fact' that the alpha claim was wrong? Because that flavour text couldve meant anything.

Although in theory the alpha claim could be wrong. And nhamlet couldve been the alpha, with TommySalami and/or Grum the 3rd/4rd wolf.

That would mean the wolves did skip a night kill because they knew someone would be escorted and wanted to try and trick us. However, given that all the other roles and claims have been vetted, this changes nothing. Au contraire, it might mean that we were wrong about TommySalami, and that once we lynch Grum, its game over for the wolves.

100% if im wolf and a wolf is getting sus i throw that wolf under the bus in any way

TnlAstatine · 03-31-2020, 04:52 PM

03-31-2020, 04:51 PMjfisherr Wrote:
03-31-2020, 04:46 PMMutedfaith Wrote: 1. How would they know the doctor would save him?
2. They were already down to 3 wolves. You don't kill 1/3 of your team for 'credibility'

How do we know 'for a fact' that the alpha claim was wrong? Because that flavour text couldve meant anything.

Although in theory the alpha claim could be wrong. And nhamlet couldve been the alpha, with TommySalami and/or Grum the 3rd/4rd wolf.

That would mean the wolves did skip a night kill because they knew someone would be escorted and wanted to try and trick us. However, given that all the other roles and claims have been vetted, this changes nothing. Au contraire, it might mean that once we lynch Grum, its game over for the wolves.

Why would we not lynch Tommy over Grum

should be either durden/muted first and then go from there
they are a good duo and the people have been strung along for the whole ride

***Chevy*** · 03-31-2020, 04:55 PM

Current vote count (as of this post)

Grum - 5
Muted - 2

*fishy* · 03-31-2020, 04:59 PM

03-31-2020, 04:44 PMDurden Wrote:
03-31-2020, 04:40 PMjfisherr Wrote: I would like to know why we shouldn’t be voting Durden over Muted atm. Durden began this whole master plan, and has often been the person we have followed and gathered most of our information the whole time. We know for a fact his information on the alpha was wrong, as Gekusoid pointed out. Perhaps Muted is the TC, he would know that Durden is a WW and is just playing the fuck out of us.

Let’s say Tommy is WW, him killing Vanilla Tron over Muted/Durden/trying to kill Doc makes zero fucking sense, unless Muted/Durden are a team.

Perhaps I’m overthinking this all. Maybe the WWs decided to attack one of their own in Durden in night 3 to give credibility to his escort claim knowing that the doc would likely save Durden.

Someone tell me I’m crazy? Idk

I can't tell you you're crazy, except on me being anything but Escort.

I'm following muted, as a seer. He could be lying, but I doubt it. It's too ballsy.

If you hang me, a confirmed villager (unless you think a ww would target their own on night three to play 4d chess), you lose a member of the village. Then, I'll also not be able to block Tommy. Which means wws will eat, and we'll lose ANOTHER villager.

I'm willing to bet grum is vanillager, because wolves are voting with us. But he's one of the few unconfirmed.

Say Grum’s a Vanillager, who are you changing your vote to then?

Samsung virtual assistant · 03-31-2020, 04:59 PM

03-31-2020, 04:49 PMGeekusoid Wrote: I'm maintaining my vote for Muted...

And as for them claiming that I voted for Dayude....I'm 10 pages deep reviewing (out of my 25 total pages on this thread)...and I have 0 votes for him. If you have a shortcut link, to where I voted for Dayude..I'll take it.

https://simulationhockey.com/showthread....pid2804331

*fishy* · 03-31-2020, 05:01 PM

@Mook is WW chat and dead chat one thing? And are they able to discuss the game?

Mutedfaith · 03-31-2020, 05:02 PM

03-31-2020, 04:50 PMGeekusoid Wrote:
03-31-2020, 04:46 PMMutedfaith Wrote: 1. How would they know the doctor would save him?
2. They were already down to 3 wolves. You don't kill 1/3 of your team for 'credibility'

How do we know 'for a fact' that the alpha claim was wrong? Because that flavour text couldve meant anything.

Although in theory the alpha claim could be wrong. And nhamlet couldve been the alpha, with TommySalami and/or Grum the 3rd/4rd wolf.

That would mean the wolves did skip a night kill because they knew someone would be escorted and wanted to try and trick us. However, given that all the other roles and claims have been vetted, this changes nothing. Au contraire, it might mean that we were wrong about TommySalami, and that once we lynch Grum, its game over for the wolves.

Wolves have never killed one of their own. Both werewolves have been lynched (Segi / Nhamlet)

Yet your claim revolves around wolves targeting one of their own (Durden) on night three.

***Chevy*** · 03-31-2020, 05:03 PM

03-31-2020, 04:59 PMスウェグキング Wrote:
03-31-2020, 04:49 PMGeekusoid Wrote: I'm maintaining my vote for Muted...

And as for them claiming that I voted for Dayude....I'm 10 pages deep reviewing (out of my 25 total pages on this thread)...and I have 0 votes for him. If you have a shortcut link, to where I voted for Dayude..I'll take it.

https://simulationhockey.com/showthread....pid2804331

I stand corrected, and I apologize for that vote Dayude. I'm glad it ended up not mattering at the time.

Mutedfaith · 03-31-2020, 05:04 PM

03-31-2020, 04:51 PMjfisherr Wrote:
03-31-2020, 04:46 PMMutedfaith Wrote: 1. How would they know the doctor would save him?
2. They were already down to 3 wolves. You don't kill 1/3 of your team for 'credibility'

How do we know 'for a fact' that the alpha claim was wrong? Because that flavour text couldve meant anything.

Although in theory the alpha claim could be wrong. And nhamlet couldve been the alpha, with TommySalami and/or Grum the 3rd/4rd wolf.

That would mean the wolves did skip a night kill because they knew someone would be escorted and wanted to try and trick us. However, given that all the other roles and claims have been vetted, this changes nothing. Au contraire, it might mean that once we lynch Grum, its game over for the wolves.

Why would we not lynch Tommy over Grum

Because we're going off the assumption that wolfs dont skip night kills, and that TommySalami is indeed the alpha. And we can block the alpha tonight and thus have no kill.

TnlAstatine · 03-31-2020, 05:04 PM

03-31-2020, 05:02 PMMutedfaith Wrote:
03-31-2020, 04:50 PMGeekusoid Wrote: Wolves have never killed one of their own. Both werewolves have been lynched (Segi / Nhamlet)
Yet your claim revolves around wolves targeting one of their own (Durden) on night three.

like i said, he's turncoat

TnlAstatine · 03-31-2020, 05:04 PM

and you're the wolf

Mutedfaith · 03-31-2020, 05:04 PM

03-31-2020, 04:51 PMTnlAstatine Wrote:
03-31-2020, 04:46 PMMutedfaith Wrote: 1. How would they know the doctor would save him?
2. They were already down to 3 wolves. You don't kill 1/3 of your team for 'credibility'

How do we know 'for a fact' that the alpha claim was wrong? Because that flavour text couldve meant anything.

Although in theory the alpha claim could be wrong. And nhamlet couldve been the alpha, with TommySalami and/or Grum the 3rd/4rd wolf.

That would mean the wolves did skip a night kill because they knew someone would be escorted and wanted to try and trick us. However, given that all the other roles and claims have been vetted, this changes nothing. Au contraire, it might mean that we were wrong about TommySalami, and that once we lynch Grum, its game over for the wolves.

100% if im wolf and a wolf is getting sus i throw that wolf under the bus in any way

How was Durden sus on night three?

Navigation

Extra Menu

About us