Login

*puolivalmiste* · 08-19-2024, 03:01 AM

We get to vote for MVPs, but what other things we should get to vote on? Would it make things better or more entertaining?

Also as we have got some feedback on the topic, let us know your opinion on what we should do with Championship Week and All-Star Week. You don't have to vote to get the TPE from this task.

25 words minimum!

You will receive 1 TPE for fulfilling all requirements.

This PT will close Sunday, August 25th at 11:59pm PST. Posts submitted/edited after the deadline will receive 0 tpe.

If you have any questions/concerns, please PM me. Tasks with malicious intent will not be graded.
Graders reserve the right to determine what is malicious. You will not be warned.

This PT is for SHL players and send downs only; it is not for SMJHL Rookies. If your player is S79, go do the J tasks instead.

***cake307*** · 08-19-2024, 03:11 AM

We should vote on everything. It is time for the Citizen's Republic of SHL! We will vote on every contract, every award, every relocation or expansion! Indeed, we will vote on whether or not we even GET to vote! Also for ASW and CW the new changes are nicer but I also have always had a pass sooooo...

Muerto · 08-19-2024, 03:15 AM

I like them separated, it doesn't seem as daunting to do 1 per week instead of cramming it all into one and having deadlines give you anxiety. I also like lately how you can write more words on topic A if it interests you more, instead of having to do x number of words on each topic.

(edit lol and then I voted for the wrong thing)

***sliceruser*** · 08-19-2024, 03:15 AM

I'm a pretty go with the flow person, i would vote on more if there is more to vote for but i do not need to have more to vote on. I trust the commissioners and HO to decide what is best to vote on in this case.

*NaomiMannequeen* · 08-19-2024, 03:26 AM

Honestly having the power to vote on a lot of the changes would be interesting for the league. I do think that potential expansion locations and names of teams could be voted on by the people instead of just HO. Other awards would be fun to vote on as well. Or at least have some of the GMs vote on some of the committee voted awards outside of the Harrak, Cross, Miller in the J and potentially their equivalents in the SHL.

*puolivalmiste* · 08-19-2024, 03:58 AM

I want to vote on who wins each playoffs games, give each team like 6 hours to make their case between each vote and then just whoever gets most votes wins that game. Would it make sense? Not really but hey would be very different at least

st4rface · 08-19-2024, 04:24 AM

I think it would be more entertaining and better in general if users could vote for all of the awards. It would consist of 50% votes from users and 50% from the administration, GMs, head office or anything else. Would be fair, I think.

Salming · 08-19-2024, 04:42 AM

Large masses are always wrong. People should not decide anything. Small group who is dedicated to make decisions should continue to do them so voting MVP is enough for large masses of people and let the committee decide other awards normally.

***Belmont*** · 08-19-2024, 06:00 AM

I think we should also get to vote on All-Star teams, I don't Know I'd FHM allows us to make changes to the All-Stars but we could have our own separate All-Star thing just in case.

As for CW and ASW it doesn't really matter to me, but if we keep them separate then I think we should do ASA tasks during ASW week instead of at the end of the season.

***Froste39*** · 08-19-2024, 06:43 AM

I'd like to have a LR MVP vote for each LR. It's an idea that I already brought up in the SSL. That way you can honour activity or friendliness rather than raw stats.

droop · 08-19-2024, 07:21 AM

Smaller split up tasks seem more ideal so it is more segmented. This would make things less extensive and more easily managed. In the end it’s the same amount of work though so it doesn’t really matter that much.

Troy_McClure03 · 08-19-2024, 07:55 AM

The less effort I need to put in to make it to 2k, the happier I am.

The only people who won't like this are the ones who had to walk up hill both ways in the summer with 10 feet of snow on the ground to get 1 tpe

***Gyro_Hero*** · 08-19-2024, 08:09 AM

I’m for the voting! And I’m okay with chatting with people to determine the best way to vote with such a large potential number of votes coming in, as well! Let everybody vote, it’ll be great! ♥️

Popol · 08-19-2024, 08:19 AM

I don't really like the idea of people voting on stuff like MVPs and other awards. Most people won't take the time to really dig into the stats. They simply vote for the person with the most points or just vote what everyone else voted. You need some people that are really dedicated to the task

**leafsftw1967** · 08-19-2024, 08:23 AM

I don't really like the idea of the SHL community voting on SHL awards like the MVP because it could turn into a popularity contest instead of voting based off stats.

Poll: Would you want CW and ASW combined into a single task worth 16 TPE? You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Absolutely combine the tasks	18.85%	49	18.85%
Would prefer one combined task	15.00%	39	15.00%
Don't really care	21.54%	56	21.54%
Would prefer two separate tasks	16.92%	44	16.92%
Don't touch anything	9.23%	24	9.23%
I have a pass but would prefer combined task if I didn't	6.92%	18	6.92%
I have a pass and don't care	6.92%	18	6.92%
I have a pass but would prefer separate tasks if I didn't	4.62%	12	4.62%
Total		260 vote(s)	100%

Navigation

Extra Menu

About us