Create Account

Poll: Would you want CW and ASW combined into a single task worth 16 TPE?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Absolutely combine the tasks
18.85%
49 18.85%
Would prefer one combined task
15.00%
39 15.00%
Don't really care
21.54%
56 21.54%
Would prefer two separate tasks
16.92%
44 16.92%
Don't touch anything
9.23%
24 9.23%
I have a pass but would prefer combined task if I didn't
6.92%
18 6.92%
I have a pass and don't care
6.92%
18 6.92%
I have a pass but would prefer separate tasks if I didn't
4.62%
12 4.62%
Total 260 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

S78 mPT #2: Make Your Vote Count! Due: Sunday, August 25th @ 11:59 PM PST
#46

I think we should have an award that is the best user of the season award as voted on by the players. This is of course different from the MVP and is more in line with sportsmanship and friendliness.

[Image: F84OPdM.jpeg]
Shoutout TheOPSquid for the Sig
#47
(This post was last modified: 08-19-2024, 11:11 AM by TheOPSquid. Edited 1 time in total.)

I think that voting on MVPs and league awards just makes the votes biased towards whoever the voter has listed in their season predictions, it also turns it into a popularity vote and not taking stats, team compositions, and individual player impacts. I would trust to leave that to the awards team, even if they leave out the obvious favourites. (cough Will Tomlander for ROTY cough)

I voted for combining the tasks, I voted for this because even though it would be a lot of writing, getting all the TPE at once would be better imo. I am impatient and it would help me get my player update in before deadlines.

[Image: TheOPSquid.gif]
[Image: v2ZHYxx.png]
#48

I don't really know what the question is asking, I guess I just do the Championship Week at the last minute anyway so this wouldnt' change anythign for me? I do prefer the only one checklist thread thing
#49

I think the voting system is great, but it should be used in specific cases such as this one. For example, if the voting system is used in the MVP, the votes might go to a player that doesn't have the stats to compete to the real MVP (Trolling).

 [Image: hbtB38x.png][Image: Screenshot_2024-07-25_171622.png?ex=66a4...56461ae57&]
                               Canada Knights Monarchs Thank you Enigmatic and Jaypc8237 for the sigs!  Monarchs Knights Canada
                                                                      [Image: qGhUIfY.png]  Monarchs Knights [Image: YADp0uU.png] 
                                             
                                            
#50

With how siloed I feel that the SHL currently is (who really pays attention to other teams? I honestly don't beyond one or two), I don't think community votes are really effective in getting legit results

[img=0x500]https://i.imgur.com/UufQtZ0.png[/img]
sig credits to @Nokazoa
[Image: wkhxpJS.png]
#51

Being able to vote on just MVP and who deserve GM recognition is fun, but there should be more silly awards. Now, I am not sure what silly awards we need as that could take more time as it would have to be something that the lay person could easily search on the index.

[Image: seamsu_500.png?ex=66b438d3&is=66b2e753&h...96a382d50&]

Credit to Vulfzilla for the awesome render pic
[Image: gXlAFBa.png]|| [Image: 8CbZQAJ.png]
#52

Although i do have a pass now, I think that these should stay separate as I think that this would make things super confusing, especially for newer players.


[Image: Sr1Fcwu.png]

#53

Make this league a democracy and let us vote for HO positions. Complete with election campaigns with bribery and all it entails. If nothing else it'll make users more aware who's part of HO.

CW/ASW side note: Please don't combine them again. Splitting it into two separate tasks has made it way less stressful.

[Image: sBUQCq8.png]

Past Players

#54

I think making them two separate tasks that are both released and due at the same times would be ideal. I usually do one at a time but it would be nice to have a few weeks to work on them.
#55

I want a vote for Least Valuable Player. Players who are active but just suck at the game must be made to realise their inadequacies and what better way to do it than a trophy, ideally one made from radioactive material

[Image: Skree.gif]
[Image: xSn0esi.png]
#56

I think going back to the 1 task like we had a few seasons ago is something to consider. I liked that more than this one, but I have a pass so I guess my vote does not really matter.

______________

40 words
______________

[Image: m59RPb7.png]



S61 Four Star Cup - Game-Winning Goal in the clinching Game 4

[Image: efischermann.gif]
#57

I think with the delay in Championship week and All-star week, it makes it easier to argue for a combined task, more so to streamline the TPE process and keep it more universal across both the J and SHL and allowing newer users an easier time getting accustomed to the TPE cycles.

[Image: sobchak.png]
#58
(This post was last modified: 08-19-2024, 01:01 PM by .Laser. Edited 1 time in total.)

Only way there should ever be voting by the general public on anything would be as a vote of confidence in any league leadership position or for a rule change of absolutely massive proportions.

Also, I like things the way they are because it allows for 2 affiliate tasks rather than 1 and as a 4-league user I enjoy having variety.

[Image: laser.png]


[Image: Virrok.png]
Thanks to EAB and sulovien for the sigs!
#59

If we were to add something else to vote on, my pick would be for most attractive player. With that said, it's clear Teemu Salami would win over @baz's Literally Wizard every single year.

[Image: dinonuggets2.gif]
Credit to Amidships, sulovilen, & enigmatic
#60

I don’t think everyone needs to vote on everything all the time. It’s okay to vote on MVP and GM of the year or whatever, but when we start voting on every little decision then I could see it getting a bit too much.




Users browsing this thread:
9 Guest(s)




Navigation

 

Extra Menu

 

About us

The Simulation Hockey League is a free online forums based sim league where you create your own fantasy hockey player. Join today and create your player, become a GM, get drafted, sign contracts, make trades and compete against hundreds of players from around the world.