Originally posted by SensNation613@May 17 2013, 10:38 PM
Hes gonna take extra shots at guys like Letang, Sid etc like you guys to do to guys like Karlsson, Spezza (If he were healthy), Michalek, etc.

Neil isnt dirty, hes been the Sens Tough guy for a while now and hes never been suspended which is something that is hard to do.

Yes, and the people that take shots at Karlsson, Spezza and Michalek are dirty. . .EVERY team has Dirty players, it's a part of the game.

Avery was never suspended(as far as I know) for anything except the stupid shit he said, he's still dirty.

Hell, Matt Cookes first suspension was in 2008. It doesn't mean he wasn't dirty before that.

Suspensions don't necessarily correlate to dirty players. The dirty plays do.

And I view a cheapshot punch as the lowest of dirty plays.

Originally posted by SensNation613@May 17 2013, 07:38 PM
Hes gonna take extra shots at guys like Letang, Sid etc like you guys to do to guys like Karlsson, Spezza (If he were healthy), Michalek, etc.

Neil isnt dirty, hes been the Sens Tough guy for a while now and hes never been suspended which is something that is hard to do.

Did u watch what he did to Sutter? Or do u have the blinders on

Neil is dirty

Former
SHL Head Commissioner S12ish-S27ish
GM S8 & S9 (Won cups both years)
2x GM Of The Year
5 Time Cup Winner
League MVP

Past Players
D - Aidan Richan - (S5 11th Overall)
C - Chico Salmon - (S17 1st overall)  

Current Player
D - Chico Smeb (S46)
SMJHL - Drafted 65th Overall by
SHL - Drafted 23rd Overall by

Lol, Neil is dirty, but Matt Cooke's one clean year makes him not dirty anymore.

#JTLogic

What he did was dirty. I didn't call him dirty. I called him a gutless puke.


And it has been 2 seasons for Cooke now

Originally posted by RehnX@May 17 2013, 10:50 PM


Yes, and the people that take shots at Karlsson, Spezza and Michalek are dirty. . .EVERY team has Dirty players, it's a part of the game. 

Avery was never suspended(as far as I know) for anything except the stupid shit he said, he's still dirty.

Hell,  Matt Cookes first suspension was in 2008.  It doesn't mean he wasn't dirty before that.

Suspensions don't necessarily correlate to dirty players.  The dirty plays do.

And I view a cheapshot punch as the lowest of dirty plays.

No you take shots to try and get them off their game, dirty players try and do alot more than that and try and injure him/end his career.

That Anaheim series was extremely physical and had very questionable hits, in a series like that, you cant suspend everyone who throw hits like those, there would be no one left on the teams tbh.

The Reich hit was between the shoulder and elbow, and the one on the Ranger player was shoulder to body. Btw calling the Despres hit dirty is idiotic, even Despres knew it was his own fault for not paying attention. Neil got a penalty on the Letang punch and Pittsburgh got a pp off it, so he basically put his team down one man.

Originally posted by RehnX@May 17 2013, 10:50 PM


Yes, and the people that take shots at Karlsson, Spezza and Michalek are dirty. . .EVERY team has Dirty players, it's a part of the game. 

Avery was never suspended(as far as I know) for anything except the stupid shit he said, he's still dirty.

Hell,  Matt Cookes first suspension was in 2008.  It doesn't mean he wasn't dirty before that.

Suspensions don't necessarily correlate to dirty players.  The dirty plays do.

And I view a cheapshot punch as the lowest of dirty plays.

we have different definitions of dirty then if you think every team has dirty players

Originally posted by SensNation613@May 18 2013, 06:54 PM


No you take shots to try and get them off their game, dirty players try and do alot more than that and try and injure him/end his career.

That Anaheim series was extremely physical and had very questionable hits, in a series like that, you cant suspend everyone who throw hits like those, there would be no one left on the teams tbh.

The Reich hit was between the shoulder and elbow, and the one on the Ranger player was shoulder to body. Btw calling the Despres hit dirty is idiotic, even Despres knew it was his own fault for not paying attention. Neil got a penalty on the Letang punch and Pittsburgh got a pp off it, so he basically put his team down one man.

There was only one dirty hit in the Anaheim series and it was the Abdelkader hit (Which was suspended) What Neal did was worse than anything that happened in the Anaheim Series imo

Thank you to My boys @Merica and @Ragnar for the lovely sigs!

Originally posted by Mr. Nice Guy@May 18 2013, 06:59 PM

we have different definitions of dirty then if you think every team has dirty players

I can't really think of a team who doesn't have a questionable player overall. But maybe I am just not thinking hard enough :lol:

Thank you to My boys @Merica and @Ragnar for the lovely sigs!

Originally posted by Maxy@May 18 2013, 07:03 PM

There was only one dirty hit in the Anaheim series and it was the Abdelkader hit (Which was suspended) What Neal did was worse than anything that happened in the Anaheim Series imo

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bJXgDCbICM
Pronger says otherwise

Originally posted by Maxy@May 18 2013, 05:04 PM

I can't really think of a team who doesn't have a questionable player overall. But maybe I am just not thinking hard enough :lol:

I want to say Phoenix/ Florida for some reason but I could be wrong.

Originally posted by Maxy@May 18 2013, 05:03 PM

There was only one dirty hit in the Anaheim series and it was the Abdelkader hit (Which was suspended) What Neal did was worse than anything that happened in the Anaheim Series imo

It's neil god dammit

Spezza is playing tomorrow, I don't think he will be a big factor in the game but he could boost everyone up. It will be quite interesting to watch

Spezza will be huge imo, he was suppose to miss 2 months and I feel hes game ready, I really hope he can bring Michalek back to himself, hes been grinding in the corners more than anything and we need him to put pucks on net.

<object width="460" height="315"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/A_1i3buHJBM"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/A_1i3buHJBM" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" width="460" height="315"></embed></object>

No sir, doesn't try to injure no one ever.

<object width="460" height="315"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/2R8maaJPeFE"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/2R8maaJPeFE" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" width="460" height="315"></embed></object>

The Despres result was clean, LOOK at where his Elbows are on the hit. He got them up and tried to hit someone high for no reason, THAT is dirty. Is Cooke is aiming for Savards head and Savard turns and Cooke only hits his shoulder, is the play suddenly not dirty? Does it change the intent? No, because Cooke is still hitting high.

And yes, every team has at least one dirty player, again, it's sadly part of the game.

In fact, I have a hard time thinking of a team that doesn't have a dirty player. . .