The SHL Hall of Fame should be located in one of the cities in which the original 6 SHL teams come from. A different case could be made for each of the locations.

West Kendall would be an optimal location to drive the interest for hockey and target a new market for the sport.

Calgary would be a great location due to the Canadian market and the hockey culture in the country.

Hamilton would be great with the Canadian market mentioned above, but also the close vicinity to Toronto as well as the American market.

Wisconsin would be great for similar reason to Hamilton, but change the face they're in the US and the closeness to the Canadian market.

Toronto would be a great location for the same reasons Hamilton would be a good location

Winnipeg would be my pick for location though as they are in the hockey crazy Canada and the team did win the first ever Challenge Cup