For: I think the cap is a good idea. However there is still a few solutions to stagnating players: Have a maximum accumulated banked TPE, or a maximum amount of years down in juniors, or even an over ager limit for each team like the CHL. This keeps the SMJHL rosters rotating regularly. And makes them more dependent on rookies.


Against: This might be one of the harder choices as the cap makes build and line chemistry most important. Personally from playing in the SMJHL I find there are a lot of other players that need to be mentioned which still doesn't encompass other consistent players:

• Borromini Cannellini (Van)
  
• Matt Kholin (Hal)
  
• Kristoffer Svensson (Mtl)
  
• Gordie Boomhover (Stl)