It would make sense to have two different defensemen awards. One of the most offensive defensemen. Players like Erik Karlsson, Brent Burns and Tobias Enstrom come to mind for guys who are clearly more offensively gifted than they are defensively gifted. That being said a defensemen could still win both awards. That's why you create a defensive award as well and if the defensemen is the best in both areas than he is easily the winner of both trophies. That statistics that make up each would be easy to decide. Obviously Assists, Goals, Points could factor into the offensive award. On the defensive side it's easy as you make Hits, Shots Blocked, Plus/Minus as the principle statistics to judge their body of work. That way we can share the wealth and given we have player builds that are geared towards multiple areas and multiple different kinds of players; it makes sense to have awards for multiple different categories.