You need to look at give aways too.. and also then the difference between the two

Otherwise makes some solid points.

But... 

Quote:McZherl/Tatu/Toner are names I see often.

I disagree, not on their merit. But on your reading of your own data. They don't appear more often than many others including the nominees .
There is one person reviewing your summary that I feel might feel sore done by which is Otis B. Driftwood.

For me the interesting complexity of this award was how to rate all the different parts together as a wholistic assessment.