04-17-2020, 12:56 PMAephino Wrote: "The SMJHL's West is better than the East"


Depends on your criteria I suppose. Just by looking at the standings and teams thus far, the East has the best and worst teams, while the West is more competitive. Then again, if you remove Detroit from the picture in the East, the range between the best and worst team by points is actually equal. Detroit's season has certainly been stellar so far, but that doesn't mean the East is definitively better than the West. 

If you look at future talent, I would argue that the East has a higher potential. Teams like Maine and Carolina are struggling right now, but they both have had early draft picks that could pay dividends in the future. Meanwhile in the West, you have teams with already-strong rosters like Kelowna and Anaheim that could be on the decline. 

Let's take soccer as an example. There is always debate about which is the "best" league: English Premier League, Spanish La Liga, German Bundesliga, or Italian Serie A. Many use the argument that competitiveness = better. You see this in the Bundesliga, where the past few seasons you have seen multiple teams challenging for the title. The 2019-20 season had 3 or 4 teams challenging for the title. The Serie A was dominanted by Juventus for years, but that has been changing, with other teams coming into the mix. La Liga was notoriously the best league for years, as Spanish teams kept winning European trophies, deeming their country the best in Europe. The Premier League was arguably the most competitive for years (in terms of title winners), but the past couple seasons it has become a Manchester City vs. Liverpool fight for the title. Overall, I say that a league is better based on the teams that have the potential to win the title.

If we use that standard in the SMJHL, I would say that the East is better than the West. Before the season started, the favorites for the Four Star Cup were Detroit, St. Louis, and Kelowna. The East is stronger right now, and it looks like it will continue to be that way in the future. 

AGAINST

against
to use your football comparison, yes, most leagues now have greater transparency. and the Eastern Division is the Premier League, as St. Louis City FC and Detroit FC are running away from the rest of the east. Newfoundland City FC's hot start has cooled off and we shouldn't be getting into Maine Villa and Carolina City. There's a major separation between second and third and it's just not as close as the west. The Western Division is Serie A in this case. Anchorage Calcio is on top, Inter Kelowna is 2 points back, and even SS Anaheim are in the race for the title. Plus, we all know that Maine Villa wouldn't beat Hellas Vancouver.
I decided, and this isn't a great methodology but I think it proves my point, to add up the point total from every team in every division. The East? 167, buoyed by Detroit. The West? 174. In fact, the top 3 teams in the West are better than the East's second team (St. Louis has 38 points compared to Anchorage's 42, Kelowna's 40, and Anaheim's 39). The West is clearly the better division due to this. It boasts 3 of the top 4 teams in the league, and the bottom teams in the West are better than the bottom teams in the East.