The obvious GOAT for Buffalo is Alexis Metzler (@Avakael). According to the Franchise Records page in SHL History, Metzler holds the Buffalo records for games played, points, assists, hits, PIM, and shots blocked. That is outstanding. In fact he is 3rd in shots blocked and 9th in assists in all of SHL history. There is simply no other case for the best, especially when you consider that he amassed all those points as a defenseman. Marius has the goals record, but he is a forward. Metzler is a Hall of Fame player who did it all for Buffalo during his tenure, including being captain for 14 seasons. There is no face of the franchise like this man. Even the latest crop of all-star D that are tearing up the league this season in Cassius Darrow and Poopity Scoop will have to bust their asses to be on the same level as Metzler.