Quote:As far as stats that can be adjusted I think that it is it. Seger ends up edging out at least one of the nominees in three of the categories and Emerson three with a tie in another.

In time on ice and short handed time Seger tops all three nominees and plays more than three times as much on the PK than Selich. For Emerson he plays more than the three nominees at even strength and more than Selich and equal to Scholz on the PK just slightly behind Kennedy Jr.

So of the nine stats here Seger has is ahead of at least one nominee in 5 and is ahead of all three nominees in 3 of them. Emerson is ahead of at least one nominee in 5 along with one tie and ahead of all three noms in 2 of those categories.

I don't particularly agree with all those metrics you used, some of them I think don't work very well, but if I do use them to look at it as head-to-head match-up then these are the results:

Scholz vs. Emerson 6-3
Scholz vs. Seger 6-3

Kennedy vs. Emerson 7-2
Kennedy vs. Seger 5-4

Selich vs. Emerson 4-5
Selich vs. Seger 5-4

So Scholz and Kennedy beat both Seger and Emerson in 1v1 and between Selich and Seger/Emerson it's super close. Which is pretty in line with my voting actually since I nommed Scholz and Kennedy but not Selich and I did nominate Emerson but not Seger, who did slightly weaker.