In looking at the index for researching this it looks like the player named "This is a placeholder" owns every single spot on the league's "Leaders" page so I am going to have to say that "This is a placeholder" should have actually made the all star team. That is just science.

Just so that I actually get credit for this I am going to say the biggest snub was Monkey D. Luffy from the Buffalo Stampede. I didn't do any research on this because it seems like it would be a pain with how the index is set up (also because I didn't feel like searching out the all star rosters as well). But the reaction from Luffy and his Buffalo gang in the announcement thread means at the very least their locker room felt VERY VERY strongly about Luffy needing to be on the all star team. If they got that worked up about Luffy not making the team this season then he must be having an amazing season and deserves all the recognition in the world.

179 words, I don't trust that 75 word prompt....