If I were to take the drink from the strange man, I wouldn't so much go for a legacy for myself, but one that would apply to my team or maybe even the entire league. The jury is still open but at this point I think I have a reasonable shot at the HOF by myself and all accomplishments I would get for myself through a shortcut like that would feel vein and meaningless, so I'm fine with just the handful of award and all-star team nominations that I already have and that aren't particularly likely to be added to. When talking about bigger issues however things might be different and I might absolutely be fine with taking a re-roll on history. The first and most obvious thing I would let the drink provide would be a Challenge Cup for the Los Angeles Panthers, not to bolster my HOF chances, heck take me off the roster if need be (maybe there is a price to pay for this kind of magic anyway?), but because the awesome people on this team deserve it. Ideally it would be two Cups actually, one for the current group and one for Wasty and some of the teams he built. It still stings to see that he had to leave this team without bringing them another cup so being able to rectify that would be amazing.