Option 1:

Before every game Murdock has to have a steaming bowl of spaghetti. Angel hair pasta, prego sauce, paremsean cheese melted on, 6 meatballs. But if there isn't enough time to get that steaming bowl in? There's only two options to take from the suspicious dude... the steak or the fish. But then we run into the issue of being faced with two choices and, obviously, one choice is going to be more dangerous than the other. Say you get the steak, it's safe but filling, but do you trust the cooking of this mysterious man. But then if you opt for the fish and it gets you sick you're screwed. Then coach is screaming "Us winning hinges on one thing--finding someone on this bench who can not only score, but didn't have fish for dinner." That's the last thing you want to hear after having fish for dinner from the mysterious food man.

All things considered, Murdock would get the lasagna.