NeonLime 2/16 [First Submission]

NeonLime 2/16 [First Submission]

Lime
Donators
ahoy ladies

02-10-2020, 08:32 PM

@Wallflower stop begging for a sig

[Image: N2lGvEu.png]

_Blitz_
Donators
Donated

02-10-2020, 08:51 PM

Cool sigs, dude

SlashACM
Registered
Certified Swiss Cheese

02-11-2020, 07:04 AM

These are sick

Carpy48
Graphic Graders
I <3 Coffee

02-25-2020, 03:33 PM

Hi NeonLime, thank you for your submissions. Your signatures have been graded by a panel (that you serve on). Values and comments were privately submitted by a panel of 6 graders, and have been aggregated below. The comments are selections from anonymous comments made by the graders in regards to what caught their eyes, potential improvements, or other things that factored into their decision making.

Comments:
1)
I like the creative approach here. It's a bit much text for my taste, but at least the arrangement works well and it pulls everything together. I think this is very underrated. Like the look of it and the vibe. Text here is on point, really well executed. I think the render effects are a little heavy, and could be worked down a bit to really make the render clearer. The text is the clearest part of this. I like the glitch effect you have going on here. I think it would be better however if the render wasn't as glitched out as the text/bg. Good render work too.
3.5 / 5 - 825k

2)
Graders were pretty split on this on:
good-
The customization is pretty cool, the text looks great, as does the render breaking the canvas. I excuse the lack of hockey because it's still SHL immersive, and ties in SHL themes where it can.
Always tough to work more than 1 render in, but I like the look of this. Really well done. There isn't too much stock work here, but the overall look of this is too clean to give lower
bad-
Good cuts here. Feel like you could've added more to this. Looks a bit unfinished.
Unfortunately I need to grade this as an SMJHL sig and this doesn't have too much to do with hockey (besides the Berserkers logo in the back).
3 / 5 - 750k

3)
Cool text and decent masking. The smoky effect could have been blended with the "renders" a little better. Not too much was done to this, but the details are carefully done and look crisp.
I like the text, but the renders look a little sloppy and low quality, unfortunately (granted it's tough to work that mask in a sig). I like the stock work though.
Some graders did not like the lack of direct hockey references.
2.5 / 5 - 625k

4)
This sig’s reviews are categorized as “great taste, medium execution”
Neat and original idea. The many little swaps are very pleasing. a little more contrast probably could have helped.
This is clearly something 'different' and quite creative. You don't see this too often here.
I like the uniqueness of this one. Jersey work is great. I would have maybe liked to see something pop out a bit more. The B at the top left seems cut off, and the letters look a little jagged, but overall great look.
3 / 5 - 750k

Total Payout: 2.95M (x2 for first submission) = 5.9M

« Next Oldest | Next Newest »

Users browsing this thread:

1 Guest(s)

Navigation

Extra Menu

About us