08-20-2018, 11:09 AM(This post was last modified: 08-20-2018, 11:10 AM by JSS.)
Sig 1: 5/10
Render falls flat and pushing it to the side of the sig doesn’t help. The render, text and steelhawks logo tries to push this sig towards a light blue theme but that background’s colour doesn’t go well with the rest. Using a light blue background would help a lot. Text being backwards isn’t something I’m a fan of and it just seems “there” rather than it being apart of the sig.
Sig 2: 6/10
Stock you used here adds something. I think the face of the render isn’t sharp enough. Text is also a bit too far from the render. and doesn’t have enough depth. I would also try putting the render in the middle of the sig rather than the side.
Sig 3: 7/10
More stock work here which I like. Jersey swap isn’t bad either. Render falls a bit flat though because of the effect you used. Making it bigger would help, but I like that it’s in the middle.
Sig 4: 8/10
Stock work is there and it’s pretty good. Render is sharp which I also like. Text also fits nicely with the rest of the piece. Tone down on the curves and it’d be even better. Not a bad piece.