Gotta go with the S53 Legends:

F - Steve Harrington - This guy just racks up all the assists.
F - Ryuuji Minamino - Quickly becoming one of the best goal scorers of all time.
F - Ethan Duncan - This is me and I'm picking so I get to be here.

D - Valentin Kalashnikov - Strongest defenseman in the league.
D - Magnus Liljestrom - The IIHF commish and a big offensive threat.

G - A Jobin - He's the only goalie left in the class, but he's a clear Hall of Famer already.