Create Account

The Hometown Discount - Do we really need this?
#61

04-08-2019, 06:46 PMZombiewolf Wrote: [Image: tenor.gif]

mfw zombiewolf doesn't approve of something I say

[Image: us4e9axucge21.jpg]

mf every day

[Image: us4e9axucge21.jpg]

[Image: 5PYmCAe.png]
[Image: doubtfulalpha.gif]
[Image: 0XJkcN5.png]
[Image: vHNIXVO.png][Image: 639861613880541184.png] Cal Juice [Image: 639861613880541184.png][Image: RyzkmSj.png]
[Image: Eo2nBCt.png] Tomas Zadina
[Image: tkMQzhf.png] Brady McIntyre
[Image: ice-level.svg]
Reply
#62

04-08-2019, 05:43 PMJKortesi81 Wrote: HTD is a way to help players stay with their teams that they want to stay with. Using Calgary as an example, they’re a closeknit group with a lot of IRL friends that play together and have fun. They don’t want to really go anywhere else.

Remembering that this is a social site, HTDs help teams that want to stay together do so. It isn’t fair to have to force someone to leave a team they want to stay with because we take an avenue away that was created to prevent that in the first place.

Others made the point of how it’s unfair to teams that have built through the draft to have to lose core players due to TPE minimums and the cap combined, so I won’t repeat it further.

HTD's are at most 4 million in savings. That really isn't the difference between keeping and losing guys you want to keep. Your own team is a perfect example of why HTDs aren't even needed. At some point the salary cap has to take effect, regardless of whether players are a bunch of friends or not. Being able to field a cup final team with 9 1000+ TPE players is pretty fair for keeping all the players you want to keep.

Removing HTDs is not the difference to forcing someone to leave.

[Image: symmetrik.gif]




Prince George Firebirds GM (S34-S36)
Toronto North Stars GM (S37-S43)
[Image: symmshl.gif]
Reply
#63

04-08-2019, 06:49 PMSleepy Wrote:
04-08-2019, 05:26 PMcaltroit_red_flames Wrote: You're not wrong (except for NOLA but that'll never happen again likely). Buffalo paid their dues and got their cup, like other teams have done in the past.

Teams should be able to be better than others obviously, but I think teams like current BUF/NOLA and past EDM and WPG were too far ahead. These teams had 1 or 2 casual members that weren't goalies, if that. Meanwhile teams featuring 5 or 6 casual members really are given no chance. I think you're seeing the extreme consequence that could happen if we took this too far, but rather if we did this correctly we'd end up with a pool of maybe 6 top teams rather than 2 clear favorites that are head and shoulders above the rest.

What's the point in building a team from the ground up then? Why not just fantasy draft the entire league every season and hope for the best. Like, idk, I think you're trying to create an issue where there isn't one and are attempting to punish teams that draft well and that people want to play for for no reason.

The league just underwent a massive expansion draft and then right after the largest draft in SHL history just a season ago. It's not like there is a super team that has won 4 challenge cups in a row or even been to 4 finals in a row. If that were the case I'd understand where you are coming from, but it just isn't.

I'm not trying to slam you're idea or put you down, I think that more discussions like this need to happen. I just think that you are seeing a problem that doesn't yet exist.

Nah I get it, it's a difference in opinion on the subject and totally fine, at least you're willing to discuss it. We definitely need more of that.

[Image: 5PYmCAe.png]
[Image: doubtfulalpha.gif]
[Image: 0XJkcN5.png]
[Image: vHNIXVO.png][Image: 639861613880541184.png] Cal Juice [Image: 639861613880541184.png][Image: RyzkmSj.png]
[Image: Eo2nBCt.png] Tomas Zadina
[Image: tkMQzhf.png] Brady McIntyre
[Image: ice-level.svg]
Reply
#64

04-08-2019, 06:53 PMcaltroit_red_flames Wrote:
04-08-2019, 06:46 PMZombiewolf Wrote: [Image: tenor.gif]

mfw zombiewolf doesn't approve of something I say

[Image: us4e9axucge21.jpg]

mf every day

[Image: us4e9axucge21.jpg]

Elite superteam Buffalo Stampede was down 3-2 in the finals. It truly shocked me when this godly team lost 7-2 in a playoff game

[Image: blurrybad.jpg] [Image: zomboy3.png]
Thank you Brandon, Fish, GeckoeyGecko, Karey, Kit, takethehorizon, and Ragnar for the sigs!
[Image: Pw202QP.jpeg]


Player Page || Update page
Reply
#65

How dare the Godpede take the finals to game 7. Where is the parity???

[Image: blurrybad.jpg] [Image: zomboy3.png]
Thank you Brandon, Fish, GeckoeyGecko, Karey, Kit, takethehorizon, and Ragnar for the sigs!
[Image: Pw202QP.jpeg]


Player Page || Update page
Reply
#66

04-08-2019, 06:55 PMSymmetrik Wrote:
04-08-2019, 05:43 PMJKortesi81 Wrote: HTD is a way to help players stay with their teams that they want to stay with. Using Calgary as an example, they’re a closeknit group with a lot of IRL friends that play together and have fun. They don’t want to really go anywhere else.

Remembering that this is a social site, HTDs help teams that want to stay together do so. It isn’t fair to have to force someone to leave a team they want to stay with because we take an avenue away that was created to prevent that in the first place.

Others made the point of how it’s unfair to teams that have built through the draft to have to lose core players due to TPE minimums and the cap combined, so I won’t repeat it further.

HTD's are at most 4 million in savings. That really isn't the difference between keeping and losing guys you want to keep. Your own team is a perfect example of why HTDs aren't even needed. At some point the salary cap has to take effect, regardless of whether players are a bunch of friends or not. Being able to field a cup final team with 9 1000+ TPE players is pretty fair for keeping all the players you want to keep.

Removing HTDs is not the difference to forcing someone to leave.

Yeahthat

Especially the part regarding a team of friends. If that's the case then either they branch out a little once the salary cap constrains them or they make a sacrifice and trade one of the other players/let them walk. The SHL might not be the most friendly place, but there has to be at least one other team a couple of the fellas could migrate to together or something. Blast and I asked to be traded as a package in the NSFL just fine.

[Image: 5PYmCAe.png]
[Image: doubtfulalpha.gif]
[Image: 0XJkcN5.png]
[Image: vHNIXVO.png][Image: 639861613880541184.png] Cal Juice [Image: 639861613880541184.png][Image: RyzkmSj.png]
[Image: Eo2nBCt.png] Tomas Zadina
[Image: tkMQzhf.png] Brady McIntyre
[Image: ice-level.svg]
Reply
#67
(This post was last modified: 04-08-2019, 07:02 PM by caltroit_red_flames.)

04-08-2019, 06:57 PMZombiewolf Wrote:
04-08-2019, 06:53 PMcaltroit_red_flames Wrote: mfw zombiewolf doesn't approve of something I say

[Image: us4e9axucge21.jpg]

mf every day

[Image: us4e9axucge21.jpg]

Elite superteam Buffalo Stampede was down 3-2 in the finals. It truly shocked me when this godly team lost 7-2 in a playoff game

I just don't get this mentality that this is all because of Buffalo. It's a little narcissistic but mostly it's childish.

Hell Winnipeg has had the best superteam in recent memory with all the players they had peaking at the same time so if anything it's more about them.

[Image: 5PYmCAe.png]
[Image: doubtfulalpha.gif]
[Image: 0XJkcN5.png]
[Image: vHNIXVO.png][Image: 639861613880541184.png] Cal Juice [Image: 639861613880541184.png][Image: RyzkmSj.png]
[Image: Eo2nBCt.png] Tomas Zadina
[Image: tkMQzhf.png] Brady McIntyre
[Image: ice-level.svg]
Reply
#68

04-08-2019, 07:01 PMcaltroit_red_flames Wrote:
04-08-2019, 06:57 PMZombiewolf Wrote: Elite superteam Buffalo Stampede was down 3-2 in the finals. It truly shocked me when this godly team lost 7-2 in a playoff game

I just don't get this mentality that this is all because of Buffalo. It's a little narcissistic but mostly it's childish.

Hell Winnipeg has had the best superteam in recent memory with all the players they had peaking at the same time so if anything it's more about them.


You mean the Winnipeg team that won two cups in 8 seasons? That super team?

[Image: blurrybad.jpg] [Image: zomboy3.png]
Thank you Brandon, Fish, GeckoeyGecko, Karey, Kit, takethehorizon, and Ragnar for the sigs!
[Image: Pw202QP.jpeg]


Player Page || Update page
Reply
#69

Removing it would help keep things simple, but I don't think it would cause too much effect either way.

[Image: JbAlQ9E.png]
Reply
#70

04-08-2019, 07:06 PMZombiewolf Wrote:
04-08-2019, 07:01 PMcaltroit_red_flames Wrote: I just don't get this mentality that this is all because of Buffalo. It's a little narcissistic but mostly it's childish.

Hell Winnipeg has had the best superteam in recent memory with all the players they had peaking at the same time so if anything it's more about them.


You mean the Winnipeg team that won two cups in 8 seasons? That super team?

The issue is not with the result, but rather the expectation. A lot of things in life tend to be more about the process than the result, but you'll hear that a lot from sports coaches (I bring this up since I assume you've played hockey or another sport at some point in your life so it's relatable). The same applies to this. The sim is about maximizing your chances if winning by having the most TPE and allocating it correctly. Therefore it doesn't always make sense to look at the results (especially playoff results due to the small sample size of each series), rather you should be looking at the expected outcome for having such a good team and maybe the regular season because although it's still a small sample size it's still larger than the sample size of the playoffs. I'll admit that a lot of predictions take the previous season into account heavily, but you'll find that generally people had Winnipeg at least winning their conference if not the cup.

S44 Predictions - Regular Season Tied-4th overall
S43 Predictions - Regular Season 1st overall
S42 Predictions - Regular Season 9th overall
S41 Predictions - Regular Season 1st overall
S40 Predictions - Regular Season 1st overall
S39 Predictions - Regular Season Tied-4th overall
S38 Predictions - Regular Season 2nd overall
S37 Predictions - Regular Season 2nd overall

That's a lot of seasons in a row for a team to be expected to make the finals/win the cup.

[Image: 5PYmCAe.png]
[Image: doubtfulalpha.gif]
[Image: 0XJkcN5.png]
[Image: vHNIXVO.png][Image: 639861613880541184.png] Cal Juice [Image: 639861613880541184.png][Image: RyzkmSj.png]
[Image: Eo2nBCt.png] Tomas Zadina
[Image: tkMQzhf.png] Brady McIntyre
[Image: ice-level.svg]
Reply
#71

04-08-2019, 07:26 PMcaltroit_red_flames Wrote:
04-08-2019, 07:06 PMZombiewolf Wrote: You mean the Winnipeg team that won two cups in 8 seasons? That super team?

That's a lot of seasons in a row for a team to be expected to make the finals/win the cup.

Not even just expectations, but from S36-S43 they were top 3 in league points 7/8 times. 3 straight seasons where they were 2nd, then 1 season in 3rd, then 3/4 seasons in 1st.

[Image: symmetrik.gif]




Prince George Firebirds GM (S34-S36)
Toronto North Stars GM (S37-S43)
[Image: symmshl.gif]
Reply
#72

04-08-2019, 07:59 PMSymmetrik Wrote:
04-08-2019, 07:26 PMcaltroit_red_flames Wrote: That's a lot of seasons in a row for a team to be expected to make the finals/win the cup.

Not even just expectations, but from S36-S43 they were top 3 in league points 7/8 times. 3 straight seasons where they were 2nd, then 1 season in 3rd, then 3/4 seasons in 1st.

That's gonna be a yikes from me dog. Looks even worse when you put it that way.

[Image: 5PYmCAe.png]
[Image: doubtfulalpha.gif]
[Image: 0XJkcN5.png]
[Image: vHNIXVO.png][Image: 639861613880541184.png] Cal Juice [Image: 639861613880541184.png][Image: RyzkmSj.png]
[Image: Eo2nBCt.png] Tomas Zadina
[Image: tkMQzhf.png] Brady McIntyre
[Image: ice-level.svg]
Reply
#73

04-08-2019, 06:57 PMcaltroit_red_flames Wrote:
04-08-2019, 06:49 PMSleepy Wrote: What's the point in building a team from the ground up then? Why not just fantasy draft the entire league every season and hope for the best. Like, idk, I think you're trying to create an issue where there isn't one and are attempting to punish teams that draft well and that people want to play for for no reason.

The league just underwent a massive expansion draft and then right after the largest draft in SHL history just a season ago. It's not like there is a super team that has won 4 challenge cups in a row or even been to 4 finals in a row. If that were the case I'd understand where you are coming from, but it just isn't.

I'm not trying to slam you're idea or put you down, I think that more discussions like this need to happen. I just think that you are seeing a problem that doesn't yet exist.

Nah I get it, it's a difference in opinion on the subject and totally fine, at least you're willing to discuss it. We definitely need more of that.

the league just expanded by two teams because the SHL grew to the point that teams were beginning to be full of 1000+ tpe players. Its not a difference of opinion. You're fabricating a problem that doesnt exist. Or at the very least, hasn't existed long enough to become visible yet. If the issue is as prevalent as you're making it out to be, forcing teams to spend 4m more per season isn't going to fix anything. Another expansion or something equally as drastic would have to take place.

[Image: cd6sM5U.gif]
arigato to everyone for the dope sigs <3

| Updates | Player Page |


Reply
#74

There are ZERO guarantees in STHS. Having a stacked roster doesn’t mean you’re winning a cup no matter what, there are ZERO guarantees that will happen. This is making a mountain out of a molehill expectations are nothing but a fart in the wind.
Not trying to draw attention but despite being in the playoffs for 6 straight seasons there are still people that always predict we miss the playoffs. Season Predictions are not taken seriously half the time and are copy and paste 85% of the time.

[Image: NiclasWastlund26.gif]
#40 Niclas Wastlund - W - VANCOUVER WHALERS Whalers / TORONTO NORTH STARS Stars
[Image: vlPUU9v.png][Image: ammBPLt.png][Image: rnZeas5.png][Image: V9MXpXR.png]

Reply
#75

04-08-2019, 08:05 PMSleepy Wrote:
04-08-2019, 06:57 PMcaltroit_red_flames Wrote: Nah I get it, it's a difference in opinion on the subject and totally fine, at least you're willing to discuss it. We definitely need more of that.

the league just expanded by two teams because the SHL grew to the point that teams were beginning to be full of 1000+ tpe players. Its not a difference of opinion. You're fabricating a problem that doesnt exist. Or at the very least, hasn't existed long enough to become visible yet. If the issue is as prevalent as you're making it out to be, forcing teams to spend 4m more per season isn't going to fix anything. Another expansion or something equally as drastic would have to take place.

I can't testify that the issue has existed since before S38 because I didn't join the league until then, but it's been around since then. I thought Winnipeg was an exception but there's been at least one team like this every season. Removing HTDs doesn't fix the problem outright, but it's a start.

[Image: 5PYmCAe.png]
[Image: doubtfulalpha.gif]
[Image: 0XJkcN5.png]
[Image: vHNIXVO.png][Image: 639861613880541184.png] Cal Juice [Image: 639861613880541184.png][Image: RyzkmSj.png]
[Image: Eo2nBCt.png] Tomas Zadina
[Image: tkMQzhf.png] Brady McIntyre
[Image: ice-level.svg]
Reply




Users browsing this thread:
1 Guest(s)




Navigation

 

Extra Menu

 

About us

The Simulation Hockey League is a free online forums based sim league where you create your own fantasy hockey player. Join today and create your player, become a GM, get drafted, sign contracts, make trades and compete against hundreds of players from around the world.