Simulation Hockey League

Looking through the thread, all RED do was claim "vanilla villager" - which sparked a little discussion about the merit of claiming that, don't think he cast a vote or pointed the finger at anyone

06-24-2020, 11:14 AMCementHands Wrote: [ -> ]Looking through the thread, all RED do was claim "vanilla villager" - which sparked a little discussion about the merit of claiming that, don't think he cast a vote or pointed the finger at anyone

I was just doing the same. Claimed vanilla and said these less forgiving rules in combination with his role made him less motivated.

06-24-2020, 11:21 AMMutedfaith Wrote: [ -> ]

06-24-2020, 11:14 AMCementHands Wrote: [ -> ]Looking through the thread, all RED do was claim "vanilla villager" - which sparked a little discussion about the merit of claiming that, don't think he cast a vote or pointed the finger at anyone

I was just doing the same. Claimed vanilla and said these less forgiving rules in combination with his role made him less motivated.

tbf tho

with REDs reputation? If i were a wolf, I'd probably go for him too. He's one of the better people at writing longass paragraphs to deduce stuff - not having him hurts.

Fuck it, we need to get some votes in, I'll go first.

I'm only basing this off of the people that are dead since they have some big reputations on the site. I'm presuming the wolves have someone who knows everyone fairly well.

Gonna go ahead and vote for luketd mostly because we need to get started eventually. I'm open to changing and listening to others, just mostly trying to get something kickstarted here.

@"luketd" say something or get got

Im just a villager, trying to figure out who I am trying to vote for. No one has been real sus yet.

06-24-2020, 12:35 PMluketd Wrote: [ -> ]Im just a villager, trying to figure out who I am trying to vote for. No one has been real sus yet.

Fair, kinda sucks cuz half the time nobody says much outside of some meme-ing, either way I feel like we have to do something today

So with Mook's "Wheel of morality", I'm still feeling that that's a pretty jester move, so I won't be throwing down for him again unless he gives me good reason to.

RED is a shocker to me having only claimed vanilla, either way as others have mentioned...he's really good at deducing things so his loss is detrimental to us all.

Luke really hasn't said much other than being a villager, but at the same time doing that hasn't really given much to suspect.

I'm in the dark here about who to suspect at all.

06-24-2020, 12:41 PMGeekusoid Wrote: [ -> ]So with Mook's "Wheel of morality", I'm still feeling that that's a pretty jester move, so I won't be throwing down for him again unless he gives me good reason to.

RED is a shocker to me having only claimed vanilla, either way as others have mentioned...he's really good at deducing things so his loss is detrimental to us all.

Luke really hasn't said much other than being a villager, but at the same time doing that hasn't really given much to suspect.

I'm in the dark here about who to suspect at all.

At this point there's no concrete information at all on anyone. The only guess we might have besides Mook would be Tnl being an Executioner, and even then they'd be a villager still so I'd still take them over a werewolf or tc. Trying to out people who are being quiet might root out a werewolf trying to fly under the radar, but also might do the same to an important villager we need. On the Luke thing, having played a few different games with Luke he usually tries to set the pace and policy as far as I can tell. For him to be quiet makes me a bit suspicious, but also I think it's equally likely he's got an ace (not not Ace) up his sleeve he's trying to save for the right moment.

06-24-2020, 12:36 PMjeffie43 Wrote: [ -> ]

06-24-2020, 12:35 PMluketd Wrote: [ -> ]Im just a villager, trying to figure out who I am trying to vote for. No one has been real sus yet.

Fair, kinda sucks cuz half the time nobody says much outside of some meme-ing, either way I feel like we have to do something today

Why Luke though? Any specific reason or just getting the ball rolling?

06-24-2020, 12:41 PMGeekusoid Wrote: [ -> ]So with Mook's "Wheel of morality", I'm still feeling that that's a pretty jester move, so I won't be throwing down for him again unless he gives me good reason to.

RED is a shocker to me having only claimed vanilla, either way as others have mentioned...he's really good at deducing things so his loss is detrimental to us all.

Luke really hasn't said much other than being a villager, but at the same time doing that hasn't really given much to suspect.

I'm in the dark here about who to suspect at all.

Still haven't heard much from a lot of people, must be nice being a werewolf this game. Faelax hasn't been paying attention apparently. HockeyIsCool's basically been MIA and Fish has been pretty quiet too.

06-24-2020, 12:53 PMCementHands Wrote: [ -> ]

06-24-2020, 12:36 PMjeffie43 Wrote: [ -> ]Fair, kinda sucks cuz half the time nobody says much outside of some meme-ing, either way I feel like we have to do something today

Why Luke though? Any specific reason or just getting the ball rolling?

The latter for the most part

i wanna hear from fish
hes way more quiet this game 

so yes i put him up 

06-24-2020, 12:36 PMjeffie43 Wrote: [ -> ]

06-24-2020, 12:35 PMluketd Wrote: [ -> ]Im just a villager, trying to figure out who I am trying to vote for. No one has been real sus yet.

Fair, kinda sucks cuz half the time nobody says much outside of some meme-ing, either way I feel like we have to do something today

I agree we have to do something but at this point, besides RED's death, what's changed since yesterday? There's still no reason to suspect anybody but we do need to get something done regardless. The two biggest connections I see between the deaths of RED and Salami are that everyone who's played with them before says they're good at sniffing things out and that they're big names on the site. The argument that someone would have to also be well connected and versed on the site to pick them off makes some sense. But, it only takes one werewolf to know that to convince the 3? 4? other wolves that it's a good idea. Still, if we figure out who that is, I'll take a dead werewolf over a dead villager every time.

06-24-2020, 12:53 PMjeffie43 Wrote: [ -> ]

06-24-2020, 12:41 PMGeekusoid Wrote: [ -> ]So with Mook's "Wheel of morality", I'm still feeling that that's a pretty jester move, so I won't be throwing down for him again unless he gives me good reason to.

RED is a shocker to me having only claimed vanilla, either way as others have mentioned...he's really good at deducing things so his loss is detrimental to us all.

Luke really hasn't said much other than being a villager, but at the same time doing that hasn't really given much to suspect.

I'm in the dark here about who to suspect at all.

Still haven't heard much from a lot of people, must be nice being a werewolf this game. Faelax hasn't been paying attention apparently. HockeyIsCool's basically been MIA and Fish has been pretty quiet too.

eh im here just being observant and trying to glean whatever information I can from the little dialogue that's been occurring. I thought Mook's post last night would get the ball rolling but nobody ever really responded to him, I agree we probably have to put someone up tonight, just not particularly sure who at this point. I agree about Faelax and HIC tho, which I noted yesterday