I didn't really follow the game after I died and realized that there was no medium, but a few thoughts:
- I still think that the "No early lynchings" strategy is bad and I'll take this game as further proof of that. I decided to not fight it this time and go along with it to see how it turns out and my fears were basically confirmed. We actually got lucky in that the Wolves didn't hit any important roles early on but because we didn't promote any discussion the village still remained utterly clueless which allowed the WWs to fade into the background while the village numbers kept dwindling.
- The role distribution/numbers could use some tweaking imho. Looking at this round we had 10 Good Guys, 5 Baddies and 1 Neutral whose gameplay tends to help the bad guys more as well. That makes it really really tough for the villagers to have a shot, in an uninformed majority vs. informed minority kind of game you need more than a 2:1 advantage for the uninformed side. Especially if you set up a system that makes early lynchings fairly unlikely, which makes it pretty likely to end up with a 9-5 or 8-5 situation after the first two nights which is almost impossible to come back from. Also quick question regarding the Medium, did we get rid of that role altogeher or did it just happen to not be in the game this time due to RNG? And broadly speaking, I personally don't need even more different roles in the game if we go for a bigger round, I would just prefer the existing ones to be in it more consistently or basically guaranteed.
Oh shit let’s goooooo Wolfies
Tbh, we thought Mook was TC all game long, him constantly pinging evok and callaing her a wolfie, as well as landing on me with his wheel of wolves, we thought he was giving us a playful way to make himself known.
This was fun! Sorry for everyone who trusted me, I hope you guys understand
06-27-2020, 09:42 AMDurden Wrote: [ -> ]So a few things for End of Game.
Would anyone want to switch from the forums to Discord? I find it easier to run things on Discord, but only if people are willing to switch.
We can do BIGGER games if we'd like. I just ran a game of 26 people. It adds a lot more roles.
If we do bigger games, I'll have inactivity rules. People who don't post, die.
Any comments/suggestions? (This entire post goes to ANYONE, not just people who played THIS game)
I'd defo be down for a discord game!
We actually expected Mook to be TC until Cement cleared him.
Id love to try this on Discord, and with a bigger group. Maybe we should implement one of those editting-tracking bots in the channel tho.
06-27-2020, 10:42 AMjfisherr Wrote: [ -> ]Oh shit let’s goooooo Wolfies
Tbh, we thought Mook was TC all game long, him constantly pinging evok and callaing her a wolfie, as well as landing on me with his wheel of wolves, we thought he was giving us a playful way to make himself known.
This was fun! Sorry for everyone who trusted me, I hope you guys understand
Tbh I did have a gut feeling evok was a wolf, but was unable to get enough evidence to start a vote against her. My goal for night 1/2 was to solidify enough in the village that I was jester, while keeping myself on the wolves radar as a threat so they might go for the kill.
I basically out-jestered the jester though and lost my traction lol
Yea lol I wanted mook to get eaten to give us a free night
uhh
so what happened n2 because i did block tnl
also never knew that blocking the alpha would kill me :o
06-27-2020, 11:02 AMCementHands Wrote: [ -> ]Yea lol I wanted mook to get eaten to give us a free night
with the fact we though for a long time that he was our TC, we didn't want to risk to kill him. Then you came and cleared him out and you guys hung the escort (though unfortunate miscommunication, i'd figure). This gave us an out to try to get the number game that same night which we did. We figured that if our TC (@
ACapitalChicago what the fuck i'd have never guessed?) was still alive in the 2 other players that were alive, we'd win the night. Killing HIC was a move to try to get ACC or Jeffie to vote with us against you since he was the one most vocal about you three and doubting.
Overall great game guys, i know it's hard on morale to get a L, but you did an AMAZING job yesterday at throwing confusion everyone. Even i was super lost and i know who were the baddies.
06-27-2020, 12:11 PMEvok Wrote: [ -> ] 06-27-2020, 11:02 AMCementHands Wrote: [ -> ]Yea lol I wanted mook to get eaten to give us a free night
with the fact we though for a long time that he was our TC, we didn't want to risk to kill him. Then you came and cleared him out and you guys hung the escort (though unfortunate miscommunication, i'd figure). This gave us an out to try to get the number game that same night which we did. We figured that if our TC (@ACapitalChicago what the fuck i'd have never guessed?) was still alive in the 2 other players that were alive, we'd win the night. Killing HIC was a move to try to get ACC or Jeffie to vote with us against you since he was the one most vocal about you three and doubting.
Overall great game guys, i know it's hard on morale to get a L, but you did an AMAZING job yesterday at throwing confusion everyone. Even i was super lost and i know who were the baddies.
Now you talk
06-27-2020, 10:52 AMMook Wrote: [ -> ] 06-27-2020, 10:42 AMjfisherr Wrote: [ -> ]Oh shit let’s goooooo Wolfies
Tbh, we thought Mook was TC all game long, him constantly pinging evok and callaing her a wolfie, as well as landing on me with his wheel of wolves, we thought he was giving us a playful way to make himself known.
This was fun! Sorry for everyone who trusted me, I hope you guys understand
Tbh I did have a gut feeling evok was a wolf, but was unable to get enough evidence to start a vote against her. My goal for night 1/2 was to solidify enough in the village that I was jester, while keeping myself on the wolves radar as a threat so they might go for the kill.
I basically out-jestered the jester though and lost my traction lol
Feel like most of the wolves were quiet and there was nothing you guys could do because most of the people weren't overly-talkative lol.
To the second bit, yeah I was trying to lay low and I thought I had it in the bag when I saw people mentioning me and decided to go silent. Guess not lmao.
so why was i not blocked if escort blocked me.....
n2: "You were ready to heal Mook, but it was not needed."
lost us the game lol sorry geck
e
if i ever play this game again i'm killing anybody who is silent fuck this lol