Simulation Hockey League

im not gonna countervote luffy because that would be mean i have zero to go off of other than that he hates me

06-23-2020, 01:51 PMGeckoeyGecko Wrote: [ -> ]

06-23-2020, 01:40 PMACapitalChicago Wrote: [ -> ]For what it's worth, I thought there was some merit to the idea that if Geck always dies first, then when Geck survives the first night maybe they're the one doing the killing instead. However, there's no real proof of anything yet. It's equally likely that the werewolves thought we'd lynch him anyway for that thought and planned around it, or just thought it would be mean to kill* them off first as seems to be the case for most games? Again, idk how anyone else plays this normally

Edit: Forgot the word kill*, sentence didn't make sense otherwise

I find it odd that I play one game of werewolf and die first night and now I 'always die first'.


I mean, yes it is 100% of the time but like

the sample size is literally one

Okay see that does sound odd now. I was going off of everyone else's comments, and to me it seemed like something that happened at least twice in a row. Not just one off and suddenly it's your thing, which would be a pretty shitty thing.

06-23-2020, 01:55 PMACapitalChicago Wrote: [ -> ]

06-23-2020, 01:51 PMGeckoeyGecko Wrote: [ -> ]I find it odd that I play one game of werewolf and die first night and now I 'always die first'.


I mean, yes it is 100% of the time but like

the sample size is literally one

Okay see that does sound odd now. I was going off of everyone else's comments, and to me it seemed like something that happened at least twice in a row. Not just one off and suddenly it's your thing, which would be a pretty shitty thing.

tbf i was EXPECTING to die again lmao

06-23-2020, 01:40 PMACapitalChicago Wrote: [ -> ]

06-23-2020, 01:34 PMACapitalChicago Wrote: [ -> ]Brutal, damn lmao

For what it's worth, I thought there was some merit to the idea that if Geck always dies first, then when Geck survives the first night maybe they're the one doing the killing instead. However, there's no real proof of anything yet. It's equally likely that the werewolves thought we'd lynch him anyway for that thought and planned around it, or just thought it would be mean to kill* them off first as seems to be the case for most games? Again, idk how anyone else plays this normally

Edit: Forgot the word kill*, sentence didn't make sense otherwise

also i pinned mook as the jester early and he stopped being goofy, and the wolves would know we didnt plan or didnt lynch him before the night.... so hardcore defending geck here?
2nd wolf?

06-23-2020, 01:52 PMGeckoeyGecko Wrote: [ -> ]im not gonna countervote luffy because that would be mean i have zero to go off of other than that he hates me

i don't hate you, i said its for discussion and it has started a discussion

06-23-2020, 02:12 PMTnlAstatine Wrote: [ -> ]

06-23-2020, 01:40 PMACapitalChicago Wrote: [ -> ]For what it's worth, I thought there was some merit to the idea that if Geck always dies first, then when Geck survives the first night maybe they're the one doing the killing instead. However, there's no real proof of anything yet. It's equally likely that the werewolves thought we'd lynch him anyway for that thought and planned around it, or just thought it would be mean to kill* them off first as seems to be the case for most games? Again, idk how anyone else plays this normally

Edit: Forgot the word kill*, sentence didn't make sense otherwise

also i pinned mook as the jester early and he stopped being goofy, and the wolves would know we didnt plan or didnt lynch him before the night.... so hardcore defending geck here?
2nd wolf?

"It's equally likely that the werewolves thought we'd lynch him anyway for that thought and planned around it" Sorry for poorly wording it, but this was meant to say that the werewolves may have thought, after the first day's discussion, that the townspeople would find it suspicious to see Geck alive after the first night and done the wolves' dirty work for them by lynching them because of said suspicions. This isn't "hardcore defending" anyone, this is trying to be aware of all the information we can be.

For what it's worth, mook was the first one to jump on Flappy's suggestion of lynching Geck first. Also, he hasn't stopped being goofy, considering he's since gone on to accuse Evok and continued supporting the Geek/Geck connection.

I can see Mook being the jester, tho he's making it a bit too obvious if he really is.

Could also be a wolf tactic to make us hesitant to lynch him, or even a villager tactic to start conversation

Tl;dr day two. I know nothing.

06-23-2020, 01:06 PMTnlAstatine Wrote: [ -> ]Flappy, luke, RED, faelax, and jeffie been pretty quiet so far.

@Durden i'm voting GeckoeyGecko to start a discussion.

I've been very vocal in these games in the past and just want to go for a bit of a different approach this time and be a bit quieter. Also as someone who likes getting discussions started early and even pushes for a day one lynch regularly, I found these new rules that basically prevent that to be quite deflating. Combine that with the fact that vanilla villager isn't the most exciting role and you have yourself a rather unmotivated RED for now :D

06-23-2020, 02:13 PMTnlAstatine Wrote: [ -> ]

06-23-2020, 01:52 PMGeckoeyGecko Wrote: [ -> ]im not gonna countervote luffy because that would be mean i have zero to go off of other than that he hates me

i don't hate you, i said its for discussion and it has started a discussion

luffy hates me

06-23-2020, 02:28 PMMutedfaith Wrote: [ -> ]Tl;dr day two. I know nothing.

It's rough because nothing will be known from any special knowledge unless someone comes forward with it, and there's no reason to do that because it puts a target on your back immediately.

06-23-2020, 02:28 PMRomanesEuntDomus Wrote: [ -> ]

06-23-2020, 01:06 PMTnlAstatine Wrote: [ -> ]Flappy, luke, RED, faelax, and jeffie been pretty quiet so far.

@Durden i'm voting GeckoeyGecko to start a discussion.

I've been very vocal in these games in the past and just want to go for a bit of a different approach this time and be a bit quieter. Also as someone who likes getting discussions started early and even pushes for a day one lynch regularly, I found these new rules that basically prevent that to be quite deflating. Combine that with the fact that vanilla villager isn't the most exciting role and you have yourself a rather unmotivated RED for now :D

thats a hella early claim

06-23-2020, 02:28 PMRomanesEuntDomus Wrote: [ -> ]

06-23-2020, 01:06 PMTnlAstatine Wrote: [ -> ]Flappy, luke, RED, faelax, and jeffie been pretty quiet so far.

@Durden i'm voting GeckoeyGecko to start a discussion.

I've been very vocal in these games in the past and just want to go for a bit of a different approach this time and be a bit quieter. Also as someone who likes getting discussions started early and even pushes for a day one lynch regularly, I found these new rules that basically prevent that to be quite deflating. Combine that with the fact that vanilla villager isn't the most exciting role and you have yourself a rather unmotivated RED for now :D

Emphasis added

Sorry, first game here, what exactly is different about this game compared to others in the past?

06-23-2020, 02:32 PMGeckoeyGecko Wrote: [ -> ]

06-23-2020, 02:28 PMRomanesEuntDomus Wrote: [ -> ]I've been very vocal in these games in the past and just want to go for a bit of a different approach this time and be a bit quieter. Also as someone who likes getting discussions started early and even pushes for a day one lynch regularly, I found these new rules that basically prevent that to be quite deflating. Combine that with the fact that vanilla villager isn't the most exciting role and you have yourself a rather unmotivated RED for now :D

thats a hella early claim

Vanilla isn't really a claim imho, it's basically the default role that everyone has attributed to them unless proven/accused otherwise.

06-23-2020, 02:32 PMGeckoeyGecko Wrote: [ -> ]

06-23-2020, 02:28 PMRomanesEuntDomus Wrote: [ -> ]I've been very vocal in these games in the past and just want to go for a bit of a different approach this time and be a bit quieter. Also as someone who likes getting discussions started early and even pushes for a day one lynch regularly, I found these new rules that basically prevent that to be quite deflating. Combine that with the fact that vanilla villager isn't the most exciting role and you have yourself a rather unmotivated RED for now :D

thats a hella early claim

It's not early at all. Everyone is assumed to claim themselves as vanilla until otherwise stated, no issue with somebody just outright saying it